Variants at serotonin transporter and 2A receptor genes predict cooperative behavior differentially according to presence of punishment

Abstract

Punishment of free-riding has been implicated in the evolution of cooperation in humans, and yet mechanisms for punishment avoidance remain largely uninvestigated. Individual variation in these mechanisms may stem from variation in the serotonergic system, which modulates processing of aversive stimuli. Functional serotonin gene variants have been associated with variation in the processing of aversive stimuli and widely studied as risk factors for psychiatric disorders. We show that variants at the serotonin transporter gene (SLC6A4) and serotonin 2A receptor gene (HTR2A) predict contributions to the public good in economic games, dependent upon whether contribution behavior can be punished. Participants with a variant at the serotonin transporter gene contribute more, leading to group-level differences in cooperation, but this effect dissipates in the presence of punishment. When contribution behavior can be punished, those with a variant at the serotonin 2A receptor gene contribute more than those without it. This variant also predicts a more stressful experience of the games. The diversity of institutions (including norms) that govern cooperation and punishment may create selective pressures for punishment avoidance that change rapidly across time and space. Variantspecific epigenetic regulation of these genes, as well as population-level variation in the frequencies of these variants, may facilitate adaptation to local norms of cooperation and punishment.public goods game | collective action | behavioral plasticity | 5-HTTLPR

Variant at serotonin transporter gene predicts increased imitation in toddlers: relevance to the human capacity for cumulative culture

“…Our study was constrained to a single population and a specific developmental stage; however, our results are corroborated by associations between the short allele and heightened sensitivity to social stimuli [13 -16], as well as altered anatomy and functionality in the brain's imitation circuitry [18,19]. Beyond social sensitivity, a vast literature on 5HTTLPR indicates that the short allele is related to diverse phenomena, including: empathy [27], cooperation [28] and dancing [29]. Following Canli & Lesch's [9] suggestion that 5HTTLPR, in interaction with the environment, may influence social behaviour by modulating neural activation in brain regions containing mirror and Von Economo neurons, we note that many seemingly unrelated observations can be reconciled by conceptualization of Both production imitation and social mimicry may contribute to cumulative culture, which arises from highfidelity imitation and social processes including prosociality, group identification and teaching [3,4].…”

Different mechanisms of risperidone result in improved interpersonal trust, social engagement and cooperative behavior in patients with schizophrenia compared to trifluoperazine

“…Atypical antipsychotic treatment blocking the 5HT2A receptor site was found to both effectively reduce aggressive behavior and to improve social competence in patients with schizophrenia. In a recent study, Schroeder et al also reported that the 5HT2A receptor gene was related to cooperative behaviors. Risperidone has also been found to enhance prosocial behavior in children with disruptive behavior and sub‐average IQ .…”

Interactions between personality and institutions in cooperative behaviour in humans

“…Previous studies have shown these to be important predictors of contributions [41,62]. Ordered logit and binomial models were also considered but resulted in little change in predictions (see [63] for results); thus, for all subsequent analyses, we used the Gaussian model.…”