Validity and reliability of selected commercially available metabolic analyzer systems

Abstract

Automated metabolic gas analysis systems have advanced considerably over the past decade. They provide an abundance of information, which is not possible by using the traditional Douglas bag method and have become an essential tool in both physiological monitoring and in the diagnosis of cardiopulmonary disease. The validity and reliability of the different online metabolic analyzer systems are not well known, with relatively few independent studies being published. The purpose of this review was to examine and evaluate current literature regarding the validity and reliability of commercially available metabolic analyzer systems. This review reveals significant differences between the available systems in the way that they capture and process basic respiratory measurements. Online metabolic analyzer systems were found to vary significantly when compared with Douglas bag methods. These variations have the potential to introduce error into the accuracy with which the health of cardiovascular system can be assessed or training loads can be assigned. Compounding this is the fact that many automated systems are a "black box", which makes it easy to generate data without the user having much understanding of how the data were generated. In conclusion automated metabolic analyser systems are a scientifically robust method for the evaluation of cardiopulmonary function. Individual researchers and clinicians must, however, be able to make their own decisions about the level of error that is tolerable for their individual needs. This presents a significant practical challenge in light of the speed with which technical developments in the field occur and we make some suggestions for the formulation of intersystem comparison studies.

Bosentan Therapy in Patients With Eisenmenger Syndrome

“…22 We chose to assume pulmonary venous O 2 saturation in patients with ventricular septal defects because a direct measurement would have required 2 transseptal procedures that were considered too risky and unethical. In addition, the assumed O 2 consumption based on body mass index tables is used in common practice in hemodynamic laboratories.…”

Determining Intensity Levels of Selected Wii Fit Activities in College Aged Individuals

“…/1091367X.2012 Heart rate was measured with a Polar heart rate monitor (Polar Electro, Inc., Kempele Finland). The rate of relative oxygen uptake ( 2 O V  ; mL/kg/min) was measured breath to breath using a TrueMax 2400 Metabolic Cart (ParvoMedics, Salt Lake City, Utah), a valid device for measuring gas consumption and production during exercise and at rest (Bassett et al, 2001;Crouter, Antczak, Hudak, DellaValle & Haas, 2006;Hodges, Brodie, & Bromley, 2005). The metabolic cart was calibrated prior to each data collection session following the manufacturer's protocol.…”

Historical Development of Nutrient and Calorimetry and Expired Gas Analysis Indirect Calorimetry

“…These systems allow the continuous measurement of expired gas concentrations and ventilation right outside the mouth and then immediately display respiratory and metabolic data for each breath, and therefore markedly increase the efficiency of the gas analysis procedure. The use of these systems has allowed for very rapid gas analysis and ventilation measurement and is less time consuming than the DB technique [4,7,8,12,15,19,24,25,28,34]. However, various commercial these systems limitations to breath-by-breath systems have been advanced.…”

“…Another concern is the failure of many computerized systems to correct for water vapor pressure (PH2O) in the expired air, as this pressure is different than in the calibration gas. Although mass-spectrometers can be altered to ignore the contribution of water vapor [10,15,19], most oxygen and carbon dioxide analyzers are sensitive to the presence of water vapor.…”