User Perspectives of Diet-Tracking Apps: Reviews Content Analysis and Topic Modeling

Abstract

Background The availability and use of mobile apps in health and nutrition management are increasing. Ease of access and user friendliness make diet-tracking apps an important ally in their users’ efforts to lose and manage weight. To foster motivation for long-term use and to achieve goals, it is necessary to better understand users’ opinions and needs for dietary self-monitoring. Objective The aim of this study was to identify the key topics and issues that users highlight in their reviews of diet-tracking apps on Google Play Store. Identifying the topics that users frequently mention in their reviews of these apps, along with the user ratings for each of these apps, allowed us to identify areas where further improvement of the apps could facilitate app use, and support users’ weight loss and intake management efforts. Methods We collected 72,084 user reviews from Google Play Store for 15 diet-tracking apps that allow users to track and count calories. After a series of text processing operations, two text-mining techniques (topic modeling and topical n-grams) were applied to the corpus of user reviews of diet-tracking apps. Results Using the topic modeling technique, 11 separate topics were extracted from the pool of user reviews. Most of the users providing feedback were generally satisfied with the apps they use (average rating of 4.4 out of 5 for the 15 apps). Most topics referred to the positive evaluation of the apps and their functions. Negatively rated topics mostly referred to app charges and technical difficulties encountered. We identified the positive and negative topic trigrams (3-word combinations) among the most frequently mentioned topics. Usability and functionality (tracking options) of apps were rated positively on average. Negative ratings were associated with trigrams related to adding new foods, technical issues, and app charges. Conclusions Motivating users to use an app over time could help them better achieve their nutrition goals. Although user reviews generally showed positive opinions and ratings of the apps, developers should pay more attention to users’ technical problems and inform users about expected payments, along with their refund and cancellation policies, to increase user loyalty.

Football Fandom as a Platform for Digital Health Promotion and Behaviour Change: A Mobile App Case Study

“…Linked to this, when discussing competing in the leagues and a personal target, it can be seen that a negative health status or having an accident were considered to be significant barriers by some participants. Equivalent concerns have been found related to diet tracking apps [ 39 ], “Well, I’m trying to…my aim is still to try and get my 60 min of exercise in a day which I’ve not been managing because I had quite a significant accident, so I wasn’t able to for a while but I’m now beginning to get that back up.” (PI4, Doris)…”

“…Linked to this, when discussing competing in the leagues and a personal target, it can be seen that a negative health status or having an accident were considered to be significant barriers by some participants. Equivalent concerns have been found related to diet tracking apps [39],…”

Mining the Influencing Factors and Their Asymmetrical Effects of mHealth Sleep App User Satisfaction From Real-world User-Generated Reviews: Content Analysis and Topic Modeling

“…Thus, the conclusions obtained may be more objective with less bias. Studies have analyzed user reviews of weight loss and precision nutrition apps [ 19 , 20 ]; however, research on mHealth sleep apps is lacking.…”

Does the use of mobile applications or mobile health technology improve diet quality in adults? A protocol for a systematic literature review

“…The recording of diet with mobile technology offers a unique opportunity to capture information that is not being recorded using traditional methods, such as the quality of food being consumed 17 . It has been reported that user satisfaction was high for dietary assessment applications, with the majority of participants preferring mobile phone dietary assessment methods to conventional methods as they provide real-time feedback on energy and nutrient intake [18][19][20] . These applications are likely to evolve and develop further in the future; with healthcare, linking to devices with biological information 21 .…”