Usefulness of hair analysis and psychological tests for identification of alcohol and drugs of abuse consumption in driving license regranting

Abstract

The implementation of the points-based driving license helps to change the drivers' behavior and is related to a reduction of traffic accidents and fatalities. In Spain, when a driver loses all points, the driving license is revoked, so the driver must enroll on a Driver Awareness and Re-education (DARE) course. However, at the moment offenders are not submitted to any test to confirm absence of alcohol or drugs of abuse consumption, even when 9% of Spanish drivers lose their driving license for driving under the influence (DUI). The objective of this pilot study was the comparison of the usefulness of psychological tests and hair analysis to identify those individuals with a chronic consumption of alcohol and drugs of abuse among drivers performing DARE courses. Volunteers were submitted to the AUDIT and DAST-10 tests. Also a hair sample was collected and analyzed for ethylglucuronide (EtG) (LOQ 5pg/mg) and 35 licit and illicit drugs (LOQ 5-50pg/mg) by LC-MS/MS. Sixty-one participants with a mean age of 37.2±11.6years, and mainly men (90.2%), were recruited and performed AUDIT and DAST-10 tests. All hair samples were analyzed for EtG and 17 samples for licit and illicit drugs. Mean AUDIT score was 9.6 (SD=7.5), showing a value ≥8 (indicator of hazardous and harmful alcohol use) in 52.4% of cases. Mean DAST-10 score was 2.9 (SD=3.3), but a score ≥6 was detected in 21.3% of cases (indicating drug abuse or dependence). Twenty-two samples were positive for EtG, 8 for drugs of abuse (8 cocaine, 2 opioids, 1 amphetamines, 1 cannabis), and 3 for medicines. EtG concentration (20.7-1254.1pg/mg) was higher than the Society of Hair Testing (SoHT) cut-off for chronic alcohol consumption (≥30pg/mg) in 21 cases. All positive cases for methadone and cannabis, and half of positive cases for opioids and cocaine presented higher concentrations than SoHT cut-offs for chronic consumption. Higher AUDIT score and higher EtG concentration in hair were statistically associated with declaration of alcohol consumption ≥4 times/month and with previous fine for DUI of alcohol. In addition, AUDIT scores and EtG concentration in hair had a moderate but significant Spearman correlation (r=0.331, p<0.05). The combination of psychological tests and hair analysis seems to be a promising tool to identify individuals with chronic and problematic consumption of alcohol and drugs of abuse. Moreover, their application during driving license regranting procedures could increase the effectiveness of DARE courses, reduce recidivism and improve road safety.

Correlation of hair risperidone concentration and serum level among patients with schizophrenia

“…Hair is easier to store than blood and is not easily affected by the ambient temperature, serving as a good biological sample. Moreover, hair is safe, stable and non-infectious without restrictions of time and place, which could avoid physical discomfort, dizziness and infection caused by blood drawing 8. Hair analysis can also offer the possibility of revealing an individual’s history of drug exposure for periods varying from weeks to months, depending on the length of the hair shaft 9.…”

Application of Psychological Analysis and Testing in Criminal Proceedings

“…In developed countries in Europe and the United States, psychological testing and analysis results can be adopted as evidence, but the premise of the psychological testing is the willingness of subjects. With the deepening of relevant disciplines, criminal psychology continues to obtain new achievements (Lendoiro, De Castro, Jiménez-Morigosa et al, 2018). China introduced the psychological testing technique since the 1990s and provincial and municipal public security organs and procuratorial organs are equipped with psychological testing instrument, which are mainly used in complex, important or suspenseful cases (Kuo, Roldan-Bau, & Lowinger, 2015).…”

Forensic toxicological analysis of hair: a review

“…Driving under the influence of psychotropic substances is a life-threatening matter for the driver as well as for the passers-by. Hair analysis in combination with psychological tests can help to trace out the drug abuse history, which can be used for re-granting or canceling the license (Kintz et al 2006;Lendoiro et al 2018). The applicants having drug abuse history have to prove fitness and undergo a physical examination.…”