Upper Secondary French Students, Chemical Transformations and the “Register of Models”: A cross‐sectional study

Abstract

UPPER SECONDARY FRENCH STUDENTS, CHEMICAL TRANSFORMATIONS AND THE REGISTER OF MODELS: A CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY AbstractThe purpose of this study is to identify how upper secondary school French students (grade 10 to 12) interpret chemical transformation with regards to the changes within molecules and atoms and in terms of intramolecular and/or intermolecular bond breaking. In order to identify and describe the students' assimilated knowledge, four questions were asked to 930 students using a written questionnaire submitted a long time after the related teaching took place. There is much research into student learning in the concept areas discussed here (atoms and molecules, chemical change, chemical bonding) as reviewed in the paper. The present study presents data from an educational system where limited work has been reported in the international literature. The French system has its own unique curriculum, and is taught in the national language (where much of the existing research has concerned learning in Anglophile systems). The research reported here found that French secondary students experienced many similar difficulties in understanding these key scientific concepts to those that have been reported elsewhere, showing the cross-cultural nature of the key educational issues. For example, many have difficulties in understanding the changes undergone by atoms and molecules in the course of a chemical reaction; many are not able to justify explicitly the breaking of inter-molecular bonds and to interpret the breaking of intra-molecular bonds in terms of reorganization of atoms, the target level of understanding in the curriculum from the end of grade 9. However, it is also suggested that some of the specific characteristics identified here are linked to the ordering and language used in the French curriculum, and such cultural idiosyncrasies may offer useful insights into both problematic and valuable aspects of science pedagogy.

Developing Learning Progressions in Support of the New Science Standards: A RAPID Workshop Series

“…Chemical Reactions:  Few high school students consider ideas such as energy and stability when explaining chemical reactions (Cokelez, et al, 2008).  Energy is used up in chemical reactions (Kesidou and Duit, et al, 1993).…”

Cognitive Dissonance as an Instructional Tool for Understanding Chemical Representations

“…Yet even decoded, they can still provide a challenge (Kozma and Russel 1997). For example, a study by Cokelez et al (2008) mentions that learners have a hard time understanding the differences between the hydrogen chloride gas described as HCl and the crystal of sodium chloride, NaCl, mainly because both descriptions are nearly identical. To conclude, the level of abstractness of chemical representations can, in other words, give quite a challenge for learners who have low prior knowledge of and little experience with the representational system of chemistry.…”

Vive la Différence? Comparing “Like with Like” in Studies of Learners’ Ideas in Diverse Educational Contexts

“…For example, the notion of an element (a fairly basic scientific concept) appears to carry different nuances in France to in Anglophone countries [56]. A student in an English school who suggested that the elements that make up [sic] a compound are still present in the compound would probably be considered to have missed an abstract, but significant, feature of how substances are defined in chemistry.…”