United and Divided: Christianity, Tradition and Identity in Two South Coast Papua New Guinea Villages

Abstract

The Motu and the Hula, two south coast Papua New Guinea societies, are linguistically related, have similar social organisation and were economically linked before European colonisation. They were both introduced to Christianity by the London Missionary Society in the late 19th century, and each appeared to incorporate the new religion into their social life and thought quickly and unproblematically. More than a century later, however, generalities about the similar adoption of Christianity by the Motu and the Hula are no longer possible. Nor are generalities about the engagement with Christianity within one or the other group, as individual Motu and Hula villages have unique histories. In this regard, while Christianity has now arguably become part of putative tradition among the Motu, some Hula are experiencing conflict between Christianity and their sense of tradition. In particular, while in the Motu village of Pari Christian virtues are appealed to as part of Pari's conception of itself as a ‘traditional’ Motu village, the situation in the Hula village of Irupara is more or less the contrary. Many people in Irupara are now lamenting ‘tradition’ as something lost, a forgotten essence destroyed or replaced by Christianity. Based on fieldwork in both villages, this paper discusses some differences in their engagement with Christianity and compares contemporary perceptions of religion, tradition and identity in both societies, informing a commentary on notions of tradition and anthropological representations of the Melanesian experience of Christianity.

Feeding Relationship: Uncovering Cosmology in Christian Women's Fellowship in Papua New Guinea

“…In fact, as I have indicated elsewhere, the doctrinal divisions in lrupara have contributed to a shared preoccupation with the pre-Christian past, and with the traditional practices which villagers see as preserving their identities (Goddard and Van Heekeren 2003). I have made close alliances with people from both congregations, although my perspective here is that of a participant in the Iru-ale UCWF.…”

Israeli Technicians and the Post‐Colonial Racial Triangle in Papua New Guinea

“…Christianity is often considered alongside kastom (TP: tradition) as dictating proper modes of social action, moral conduct, and belief . Yet it is also known as having a recent history that derives from European contact and is sometimes blamed for the loss of ‘culture’ (Goddard and Van Heekeren ; Golub ). This ambivalent history then raises the possibility that, like government and other modern systems, Christianity has not been properly assimilated into Melanesian culture, social life, and personal disciplines, hence the moral failures mentioned above and the need for religious revival (Robbins ).…”

Josephine's Journey: Gender‐based Violence and Marian Devotion in Urban Papua New Guinea

“…Various scholars have since responded to Barker's call, but most of these studies (for example Goddard & Van Heekeren 2003;Jebens 2005;Robbins 2004) have focused on rural indigenisations of Christianity and processes of transformation. Urban experiences and constructions of Christianity remain largely un-addressed.…”