(Unintended) Transport impacts of an energy-environment policy: The case of CNG conversion of vehicles in Dhaka

Abstract

Motor vehicles are one of the major sources of air pollution in Dhaka, the capital of Bangladesh. The government took various policies to convert the petroleum vehicles on road to run on compressed natural gas (CNG), which allows both air quality improvements and energy security benefits. One of the market friendly policies to encourage the fuel switch was to increase the price differential between CNG and petrol and diesel. This has allowed a wide-scale adoption of CNG as the fuel of choice. However, several years into the policy, there is now a widespread belief among the policymakers that the CNG conversion may have increased car ownership and car travel due to their lower running costs, resulting in more congestion and a reversal of the strategy is on the cards. It is therefore important to test the hypothesis whether CNG conversion had genuinely increased car ownership and car travel in Dhaka city. This paper presents the results of a questionnaire survey and an econometric intervention analysis to understand the impact of CNG conversion on car ownership and car travel in Dhaka. Attention is also given to disentangle the self-selection and price-induced travel effects of CNG conversion. Results show that ownership did not increase, but travel of on-road vehicles increased due to the CNG policy.However, additional congestion costs are still around one-half of the health benefits brought about by the policy.

The effects of e-ridehailing on motorcycle ownership in an emerging-country megacity

“…The method is especially useful if there is a long timeseries or the temporal data has finer frequency than annual. Examples of application of this method are Noland et al (2008), Park et al (2016), Wadud (2014Wadud ( , 2020. However, given we have only two years of post-intervention data, a statistical comparison of predicted and observed data using this method will not be very meaningful.…”

“…Given the econometric model estimation depends on yearly variations in the data, rather than the absolute value, this is less problematic if the growth rate is similar in Dhaka and the rest of the country. This is possibly a strong assumption, however, previous academic work has used similar assumptions in the absence of reliable GDP or GNI data for Dhaka city (Wadud 2014). Fig.…”

Congestion impacts of shopping using vehicle tracking data

“…Using an average speed of 9.7 kph on a regular weekday, 11.4 kph on a weekday when shops are closed and an assumed free flow speed of 30 kph, the congestion costs increases by 9.5%. 6 There are no government estimates for the costs of congestion in Dhaka, but other estimates range from USD 0.8 Billion to USD 2.8 Billion a year (Wadud 2014). Therefore, shopping related activities and traffic flow disruption results in an additional congestion costs of between USD 69 Million and 243 Million a year in Dhaka.…”

“…A priori expectation is that zones or roads with fewer markets will experience smaller differences in speeds between days when shopping is open and closed. Given the lack of data on market density along the 6 7 Note that the original congestion cost estimates, which are summarised by Wadud (2014) from other studies, have several limitations and care must be exercised in using these numbers. Open Closed roads or in zones, we choose two roads with visibly different densities of shopping along them.…”

Low Emission Scenarios Analysis In the Urban Transportation In Dhaka, Bangladesh

“…CNG buses and minibusses accounted for more than 70% of all buses and minibusses. This accounts for almost 75% of Dhaka motor vehicles (excluding motorcycles) (Wadud, 2014). CNG conversion was mandated for all government vehicles.…”