“…Although some research (Awan et al, 2020;Churchill et al, 2018;Esteve & Tamarit, 2012;Shahbaz et al, 2013;Xie et al, 2022) have supported the EKC hypothesis, there are studies (Al Sayed & Sek, 2013;Islam et al, 2022;Ng et al, 2022;Özokcu & Özdemir, 2017) that do not prove it. According to these studies, the relationship between the environment and economic growth has other trends like a monotonically increasing trend (Bagliani et al, 2008), U-shaped (Wang et al, 2011), N-shaped (Lorente & Álvarez-Herranz, 2016;Poudel et al, 2009), and inverted-N-shaped patterns (Özokcu & Özdemir, 2017).…”