Understanding the Impact of Relationship Disruptions

Abstract

Personal relationships between salespeople and customers are essential for the success of business-to-business relationships, and research has shown that a change of the salesperson can severely harm financial performance. However, such interpersonal relationship disruptions may also have positive effects by encouraging vitalizing reexplorations of the relationship. Using multilevel loyalty theory and relationship life cycle theory, the authors offer a comprehensive conceptualization of potentially countervailing consequences of relationship disruptions. In particular, disruptions may have different effects on resale revenue (from previously sold products) versus new sale revenue (from newly sold products), contingent on both the history and expected future development of the relationship. Therefore, this study examines moderators on the firm-level relationship prior to disruption and salesperson relationship management afterward. Longitudinal data from 2,040 customers of an international business-to-business firm reveal that a disruption can increase overall performance by more than 29%, depending on the firm-level relationship before disruption and the new salesperson’s relationship management. Managers can use these findings proactively to evaluate and manage the risks and opportunities involved in relationship disruptions.

The human side of digital transformation in sales: review & future paths

“…Relatedly, in the stages of the personal selling process which particularly require empathetic skills and adaptive selling (Alavi, Habel, and Linsenmayer 2019), i.e., in the customer interaction and after-sales service, effectiveness of automation through new digital sales technologies may be strongly limited. This finding is in line with recent works indicating that personal attention through salespeople is especially warranted in complex and high-priced contexts (Alavi et al 2021;Habel et al 2020;Lawrence et al 2019;Schmitz et al 2020). Interestingly, this finding is in line with a recent study of the prestigious World Economic Forum on the future of work indicating that in complex business contexts the number of sales and marketing jobs is bound to rise in response to digitalization initiatives (World Economic Forum 2018).…”

Reality Check: Infusing Ecological Value into Academic Marketing Research

“…Converting findings into stakeholder implications is much more than just stating that stakeholders should account for these results when making decisions; rather, it involves actually giving specific advice when possible. Some good examples include offering decision flow charts, providing a table or other visualization of key results in a format suitable to stakeholders acting on the paper’s insights (e.g., Table 7 from Schmitz et al 2020, Figure 2 from Campbell and Schau 2019), or using short case examples (see Chandrasekaran, Tellis, and James 2021) to demonstrate the key insights from the paper. Reality Check 22: Have you translated your findings into ideas, metrics, and actions that support stakeholder understanding and decision making? …”

Corporate social responsibility in luxury contexts: potential pitfalls and how to overcome them

“…Customer loyalty is a vital consideration, given that maintaining long-term customer relationships is crucial to long-term financial success (e.g., Reichheld and Sasser 1990;Reinartz and Kumar 2000;Wieseke et al 2014) and growth (Keiningham et al 2008). Indeed, if companies aim to be financially successful in the long run, they must build a loyal customer base rather than focus on constantly acquiring new customers (Schmitz et al 2020). Thus, when customers perceive a luxury company's CSR activities as extrinsically motivated and are less loyal to the company, it is likely to harm the firm's long-term financial success through decreased sales revenue growth.…”