Understanding the Factors and the Corresponding Interactions That Influence Construction Worker Safety Performance from a Competency-Model-Based Perspective: Evidence from Scaffolders in China

Abstract

Purpose: Construction workers’ reactions to safety-related issues during operation vary from person to person due to their different occupational levels, which can be attributed to various influencing factors and their correspondingly complicated interactions. This research aims to propose an integrated framework to combine the concepts of these factors and provide a holistic interpretation of the interrelationship among them. Methods: Based on items that were mainly extracted from competency theory, exploratory factor analysis (EFA) and confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) were conducted to identify the critical factors from the data collected from 243 scaffolders on Wuhan Metro construction sites. The interactions among the identified factors were then analyzed, and the safety competency model was thus established with the use of structural equation modeling (SEM). Results: A total of 17 items were identified as critical to workers’ safety competency, and these were further tested and attributed to four factors: (1) individual character and inclination; (2) self-adjustment and adaptability; (3) working attitudes; (4) safety-related operation qualification. Subsequent analysis showed that all the factors significantly contributed to one’s safety competency, and individual character and inclination contributed most to the formation of one’s ability, while the intermediating effects of self-adjustment and adaptability should not be neglected both in theoretical and practical terms. The resultant safety competency model consisting of these four factors was revealed to share a hierarchical structure with the classical competency model. Significance: This study provided an integrated theoretical framework and a set of modeling approaches to combine the related concepts and facilitate a greater understanding of construction safety in terms of workers’ characteristics and behaviors. Practical implications: This study presented a tentative approach for assessing construction workers’ safety competency, as well as emphasized to the managers and professionals the necessity of developing training systems to ensure workers are integrated into a crew in an appropriate and smooth manner. Limitations and Future Work: The volume and the scope of samples impeded the study from achieving a more generalized result and a more cost-efficient data collection approach is in need of development for a comprehensive and in-depth investigation.

Violent behaviour on construction sites: structural equation modelling of its impact on unsafe behaviour using partial least squares

“…Improper placing and stacking of objects and materials in dangerous locations. Problems associated with improperly placing and stacking objects in dangerous locations are widely reported in literature (Liang et al, 2019;Nadhim, 2019;Lawton, 2014, Aksorn andHadikusumo, 2007). Improper stacking and storage of objects and materials can result in serious injuries to workers and damages to costly materials (Lawton, 2014).…”

“…Improper positioning of tasks has the tendency to cause workers to fall, especially, from heights. Also, improper posture for tasks, which is highly evident when workers take short cuts by climbing or jumping from high levels instead of using ladders could result in serious injuries (Liang et al, 2019;Lop et al, 2019;Aksorn and Hadikusumo, 2007).…”

Occupational Health and Safety, Work Discipline, Leadership Style Affect Employee Performance

“…This finding is in line with the statement (Apandi, 2018;Hafid, 2018;Widari et al, 2018) that occupational safety and health, work discipline, and leadership style are factors that can significantly influence employee performance in the company. This can be due to the fact that at work, employees need a sense of security and comfort in order to work optimally (Liang et al, 2019). In addition, optimal performance is also obtained by obeying the rules or norms set by the company, for example coming and going from work according to the time set by the company.…”

Model of burnout, depression, and work performance among nurses in China: a questionnaire survey.

“…Many factors affect employee performance. Some researchers believe that job performance is a function that is closely related to personal factors such as anxiety [5,6]. Burnout it is not limited to emotional exhaustion and workload and high work intensity are not the only factors that contribute to burnout development.…”