Undergraduate socialization in medical education: ideals of professional physicians’ practice

Abstract

A study of professional socialization in a medical education programme in Sweden is presented. The aim of the study was to explore ideals held within the educational practice concerning what constitutes an effective professional practitioner. Sixteen respondents from educational practice, eight teachers and eight students, were interviewed regarding their views on what constitutes 'the ideal physician', i.e. the desirable end product of medical education. Their responses were classified into six virtues: wisdom, discipline, humility, empathy, maturity and strength, each with corresponding vices. These virtues and vices reflect a desired direction for professional socialization during medical training and the professional performance of physicians. They also provide useful indicators of what has been described as medicine's hidden curriculum. Implications for curriculum planning and the organization of learning in medical education are discussed.

Learning in the Real Place

“…4,5 Boys in White, the classic book on students' socialization in medicine, depicts how medical students become socialized into the profession and the culture in medical training. 6 Several recent studies shed additional light.…”

‘You’re judged all the time!’ Students’ views on professionalism: a multicentre study

“…Students’ views on professionalism are well documented in the literature, 12–16 but few accounts describe the opinions of Phase 1 students 17 . Phase 1 medical students are those in the first 2 years of a 5‐year medical degree.…”

Negotiating the Normal Birth : Norms and Emotions in Midwifery Education

“…Hence, what the practitioner can do is interwoven with "medical virtues", that is with ideas of using both technical medical knowledge and humanistic skills in the patient encounter. Studies by Clouder (2003) and Lindberg (2009) also explore the ideals that medical students encounter during their education. They show the importance of not only learning what to do but also how to do it the "proper" way in a community of practice.…”

“…In studies of healthcare professions, questions have been raised about what it means to be a "good" practitioner (Halldorsdottir and Karlsdottir 2011) and how students can learn the virtues of the "good" professional role (Clouder 2003, Duncan, Cribb and Stephenson 2003, Lindberg 2009). Sigridur Halldorsdottir and Sigfridur Inga Karlsdottir (2011) have analyzed "the primacy of the good midwife" and what they call "core values", that is, norms about how to be a professional midwife.…”