Uncovering degrees of workplace bullying: A comparison of baccalaureate nursing students’ experiences during clinical placement in Australia and the UK

Abstract

Bullying in health workplaces has a negative impact on nurses, their families, multidisciplinary teams, patient care and the profession. This paper compares the experiences of Australian and UK baccalaureate nursing students in relation to bullying and harassment during clinical placement. A secondary analysis was conducted on two primary cross-sectional studies of bullying experiences of Australian and UK nursing students. Data were collected using the Student Experience of Bullying during Clinical Placement (SEBDCP) questionnaire and analysed using descriptive and inferential statistics. The total sample was 833 Australian and 561 UK students. Australian nursing students experienced a higher rate of bullying (50.1%) than UK students (35.5%). Students identified other nurses as the main perpetrators (Aust 53%, UK 68%), although patients were the main source of physical acts of bullying. Few bullied students chose to report the episode/s. The main reason for non-reporting was fear of being victimised. Sadly, some students felt bullying and harassment was 'part of the job'. A culture of bullying in nursing persists internationally. Nursing students are vulnerable and can question their future in the 'caring' profession of nursing after experiencing and/or witnessing bullying during clinical placement. Bullying requires a zero tolerance approach. Education providers must develop clearer policies and implement procedures to protect students - the future nursing workforce.

Factors influencing the practice of new graduate nurses: A focused ethnography of acute care settings

“…This phenomenon and its negative consequences have been documented extensively in recent years, going from distrustful relationships between nurses and a lack of consideration to malicious behaviours, such as bullying and intra-professional violence (Birks et al, 2017;Kelsey, 2017;Laschinger et al, 2010;Simons & Sauer, 2013). Despite awareness of the problem for several years and initiation of institutional policies, it seems these behaviours remain present in the care units and are experienced by nursing students during clinical placements (Birks et al, 2017;Courtney-Pratt, Pich, Levett-Jones, & Moxey, 2018). These behaviours can lead to a negative impact on nursing practice, quality of care, and increase the intention to leave the profession (Vogelpohl, 2011).…”

Incivility through the continuum of nursing: A concept analysis

“…Biases can trigger unfair treatment or favoritism for students. From the articles reviewed, these biases included gender, sexual orientation, and cultural bias …”

“…The described demeaning actions were mainly verbal. In the literature, demeaning actions included rude, sarcastic remarks, passive‐aggressive statements, belittling language, and gossiping …”

“…Dismissive actions can be verbal or nonverbal. Eye‐rolling and ignoring an individual are two actions described in the literature. Dismissive actions were found to undervalue the individual and his or her contributions to the nursing profession …”

Enhancing student competency in risky clinical environments: Evaluating an online education program

“…Ultimately, results signal Risk Aware's capacity to contribute to healthcare education and training. Placement risk impacts both trainees (Birks et al, ; McCloughen & Foster, ) and professional healthcare workers (Mayhew, ; McDiarmid, ), calling for a move towards improved risk management training (Beech & Leather, ). Given preliminary evidence of Risk Aware's effectiveness in its pilot phase, further investigation of its use in diverse settings is warranted.…”