Two faces of shrimp aquaculture: commonising vs. decommonising effects of a wicked driver

Abstract

Much coastal fisheries literature supports the idea that shrimp aquaculture has the potential to cause considerable social and environmental destruction. The aim of the paper is to highlight the two faces of shrimp aquaculture as a wicked driver, emphasizing its potential role in activating systematic conversion of lagoon -based fisheries commons to non-commons and vice versa. We use the cases of aquacultureled privatisation in Chilika Lagoon, located in the Bay of Bengal area of India, and collective action surrounding shrimp aquaculture in Northwestern Sri Lanka. For both studies, data are collected through mixed research methods, including semi-directive interviews, focus group discussions, and participant observations. Our analysis shows clear evidence that shrimp aquaculture can potentially contribute to either making commons or losing commons depending on the context and influences of multi-level drivers. Aquaculture-led factors contributing to the process of losing commons in Chilika are: large-scale, individually owned aquaculture operations; encroachment of customary fishery commons; loss of commons rights (access and entitlements); breakdown of commons institutions; policy changes; caste politics and resource conflicts; ecological disturbances; change in fishing practices. In Sri Lanka, aquaculture related factors contributing to making commons are: coordinating discharge; built-in incentive for stewardship; multi-level commons institutions; collective decision-making; bottom-up management approach; mixed commons regime; and small-scale operations.

Blue growth and blue justice: Ten risks and solutions for the ocean economy

“…Spatial displacement of local resource users, small-scale fishers and Indigenous Peoples is also evident across a number of sectors, including aquaculture [45,71,72], oil and gas development [8,73,74], seawater desalination plants [75], and tourism [76]. These spatial enclosures were already occurring prior to the implementation of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), which established exclusive economic zones (EEZ) in the 200 nautical mile maritime area bordering nations providing clear authority and a mechanism through which states could allocate use and property rights in the ocean [77].…”

Recent advances in Shrimp aquaculture wastewater management

“…This also leads to socio-economic problems such as mass migration to urban areas, marginalization, and rural unemployment, and food insecurity, loss of institution, social unrest and conflicts. A study at Chiliki Lagoon in the Bay of Bengah India showed that out of 140 fishing villages surveyed, up to 135 fishers complained of being adversely affected by shrimp aquaculture operations in the area (Galappaththi and Nayak, 2017).…”

Institutions and institutional changes: aquatic food production in Central Luzon, Philippines

“…Informal institutions are typically tacit and are maintained and reproduced by being imbibed into ways of thinking and repeated social practice at the individual and community levels (Manlosa 2019 ). Examples include gender norms in aquaculture and coastal settings (Weeratunge et al 2010 ; Kruijssen et al 2018 ) and customary resource management systems (Galappaththi and Nayak 2017 ). In some cases, informal institutions are later formalised.…”