Patients presenting with right-sided heart failure represent a clinical challenge with numerous potential etiologies and limited treatment options. This report presents a challenging case involving right-sided heart failure due to persistent tricuspid regurgitation (TR) exacerbated by the placement of a right ventricular (RV) pacing lead after mitral valve repair. Ultimately, lead extraction resulted in decreased TR severity, improvement in RV function, and resolution of heart failure symptoms, highlighting the importance of prompt recognition of lead-associated TR.