Abstract:30 31As many seaduck populations around the world have been reported to decline 32 there is an increasing demand for knowledge about intrinsic and extrinsic 33 factors determining population dynamics of these species. 34In this study we analyzed long term dynamics of the summer population of 35 velvet scoters (Melanitta fusca) breeding in the Åland archipelago in the 36 Baltic Sea; in particular, we examined the influence of winter weather and 37 density dependence on population change. The studied population … Show more
“…For this region, the climate is projected to become progressively warmer and wetter, but also more variable, with an increase in both warm and wet extremes over the next several decades (Thibeault and Seth 2014). Extreme or adverse weather has been shown to interrupt breeding (Mearns and Newton 1988;Olsen and Olsen 1989) and can regulate populations (Hartman et al 2013). Variation in precipitation can help explain changes in annual fecundity and can have significant effects on population growth (Johnson and Geupel 1996).…”
“…For this region, the climate is projected to become progressively warmer and wetter, but also more variable, with an increase in both warm and wet extremes over the next several decades (Thibeault and Seth 2014). Extreme or adverse weather has been shown to interrupt breeding (Mearns and Newton 1988;Olsen and Olsen 1989) and can regulate populations (Hartman et al 2013). Variation in precipitation can help explain changes in annual fecundity and can have significant effects on population growth (Johnson and Geupel 1996).…”
“…The amount of error was selected from a uniform distribution bounded between 0% and 25% and applied to the population size at the previous time step. The upper bound of the error distribution was the highest value reported by the metaanalysis studies (Hartman et al 2013). This was considerably larger than the error reported in other studies, e.g.…”
Section: F U N C T I O N a L S H A P E O F D E N S I T Y -D E P E N Dmentioning
confidence: 50%
“…The upper bound of the error distribution was the highest value reported by the meta‐analysis studies (Hartman et al . ). This was considerably larger than the error reported in other studies, e.g.…”
Summary
Although density‐dependent regulation of population growth is thought to be relatively widespread in nature, density‐independent models are often used to project the population response to drivers of change. Such models are often considered to provide a maximum estimate of mortality and therefore offer a precautionary approach to impact assessment. However, this perception assumes that density dependence operates as compensatory (negative density dependence), and overlooks that other forms of density dependence, such as depensation (positive density dependence), would generate a contrasting population response.
Currently, there is debate about including density‐dependent mechanisms in models that assess the impact of offshore wind farms on marine bird populations. Density dependence is considered poorly understood for this group of species. Consequently, it is either excluded from assessments, or incorporated in a compensatory form that has little empirical validation.
We reviewed the evidence for compensatory and depensatory regulation of 31 marine bird species, and conducted a meta‐analysis to examine the functional shape of density‐dependent population growth. The evidence was also evaluated in relation to established species‐specific indices of wind farm vulnerability in order to assess whether compensatory mechanisms are likely to offset losses associated with collision or displacement.
Compensatory regulation was reported across all of the demographic processes and focal groups considered, and was attributed to a variety of causal mechanisms. The strength of compensatory population growth appeared consistent between colonies; however, the regulation of productivity was highly context‐dependent with a similar number of studies reporting compensatory, depensatory and insignificant effects. Depensation was consistently attributed to increased rates of predation at lower population densities.
Synthesis and applications. We conclude that among marine bird species with high vulnerability to wind farms, compensatory regulation is unlikely to offset large and sustained losses from the breeding population. In addition, depensation has the potential to accelerate population declines and generate local or regional extinctions, especially in smaller colonial species. Consequently, density‐independent models will not offer a consistently precautionary approach for assessing the potential impact of wind farms on marine bird populations. Instead, assessments should examine the potential population response using a range of density‐dependent structures.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.