Treatment of depression with antidepressants is primarily a psychological treatment.

Abstract

Depression treatment with antidepressants is generally described as evidence-based. However, generalizations to practice recommendations seem to us to rest on the tacit assumption that treatment outcome in research trials is the sum of three factors: specific effects of the drug, expectancy effects (placebo), and spontaneous recovery. Because randomization isolates the specific effects of the drug, trials showing significant drug effects are used as evidence for prescribing the drug regardless of context. Drawing on Wampold's (2001) description of two metamodels of psychotherapy, the authors argue that available empirical evidence indicates that depression treatment with antidepressants is primarily a psychological treatment. This conclusion has far-reaching consequences for the scientific status of contemporary treatments for depression. It also affects what the doctor should focus on in a treatment with antidepressants and how to act when the patient is treatment resistant. In order to achieve the results obtained in clinical trials, the quantity and quality of support from the doctor is more important than pharmacological concerns, such as adequate doses of medicine. When faced with a treatment resistant patient, relationship factors rather than pharmacological factors should be in focus. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved).

From Dynamic Lesions to Brain Imaging of Behavioral Lesions: Alloying the Gold of Psychoanalysis with the Copper of Suggestion

“…. Beyond showing that antidepressants are comparable to placebos in many contexts within depression (Kirsch, 2010;Kirsch et al, 2008), recent studies report that the efficacy of antidepressants in the treatment of depression is due more to patients' experience of their relationship with the prescriber than to the chemical properties of the drug (Ankarberg & Falkenstrom, 2009). These findings underscore the large role that suggestion seems to play in any therapeutic setting, including psychoanalysis.…”

Evaluation of a brief art psychotherapy group for adults suffering from mild to moderate depression: Pilot pre, post and follow-up study

“…While the current study did not include a control group, it may not be concluded with certainty whether this effect occurred as an implication to the therapy or whether it was due to other reasons, including a possible spontaneous recovery from depression (Ankarberg & Falkenström, 2008).…”

Depression, Antidepressants and Cognitions: Silent Schemas in the Walking Wounded

“…Therapeutic professional support is posited to be a primary causative factor for success even in pharmaceutical-mediated symptom reduction, surpassing other medication related factors [27]. The implication is that professional relationships associated with obtaining prescriptions may address cognitive schema patterns, generating a deeper level of change than would be attributable to chemical intervention alone.…”