“…One proposes that the tunnelling states are not required, only an off-center vibration of the guest ions, 13,14 and another proposes that the guest ions don't play a major role at all at low temperatures, but rather it is the phonon scattering on charge carriers that leads to the glasslike behavior. 15,16,17,18 In this work we address the issue by performing single crystal x-ray diffraction (SCXRD), thermal conductivity κ(T ) and heat capacity C p (T ) experiments on Ba 8 Ga 16 Sn 30 (BGS) and Ba 8 Ga 16 Ge 30 (BGG) crystals, which have been tuned through the crystal growth process to display n-type or p-type majority charge carriers as a result of small imbalances in their Ga:Ge or Ga:Sn ratios. 19,20 By analyzing the differences and similarities between the behaviors of these samples, we can test the applicability of the various models proposed to explain the origin of unusual glasslike behavior, in this case observed for p-type samples whereas the n-type samples show the normal crystalline peak.…”