Transdisciplinary case studies as a means of sustainability learning

Abstract

Purpose -This paper aims at presenting the theoretical concepts of the transdisciplinary case study approach (TCS), which is a research and teaching approach developed and elaborated at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH), as a means of transition support. Design/methodology/approach -The paper reveals the historical roots of case studies, transdisciplinarity and sustainable development as teaching and research paradigms. The TCS approach is presented, which has been developed at ETH for supporting transition management of regional, urban, and organizational systems. This approach is entrenched by an ontology that reveals the basic characteristics of ill-defined transition problems, an epistemology that refers to Probabilistic Functionalism and distinguishes between multi-layered systemic and normative epistemics, a methodology that includes a set of methods for case representation (including modelling and projection), assessment, and strategy building, and a project management model that refers to more than a dozen TCSs in the field of sustainable development. Problems of validity of TCSs as a research methodology are discussed. Findings -Three major strengths of the TCS approach presented in the paper are: that it is based on three sound paradigms, which focus on different, relevant characteristics of complex, human-environment systems; i.e. the case study approach, transdisciplinarity and sustainable development, that it is strictly organized according to an elaborated and consistent theoretical framework that includes ontological, epistemological, methodological, and organizational considerations, and that it is itself subject to an ongoing inquiry and adaptation process. All theoretical considerations of the paper are clarified be elaborated examples from the more than 10 years experience with TCS of the authors. Practical implications -The paper gives a comprehensive overview of the theoretical foundation of TCS that might assist other scientists engaged in case study research and teaching to further develop their approaches. Additionally, relevant topics for further research in the field of TCS are presented which hopefully induce an inspiring discussion among case study researchers. Originality/value -As far we know, this paper is one of the first that presents a comprehensive and theoretically sound overview of applying transdisciplinary case studies as means of sustainability learning. Thus, it can be seen as a first, crucial step for establishing the new research field of TCS The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at research and a sound research community of complex, transdisciplinary problem solving towards sustainability learning.

Eight Tons of Material Footprint—Suggestion for a Resource Cap for Household Consumption in Finland

“…Thus, it is intended to support the creation of new ways of low resources individual lifestyles. It, thus, refers to a variety of approaches of transition and action orientated research, such as [21][22][23][24][25][26]. The material footprint as a method for calculating the natural resource use of households is briefly described in Section 2.1.…”

Transdisciplinarity in higher education for sustainability: How discourses are approached in engineering education

“…In general Td has been stated differently, whether focusing on philosophical reflection, critique, or the role of science in society where interdisciplinary research occurs when there is collaboration between academics, whereas transdisciplinarity involves cooperation with nonacademics (Balsiger, 2004;Lang et al, 2012;Scholz et al, 2006;Stauffacher et al, 2006). Meanwhile, Thomson Klein (2004; noting the increasing of Td approaches, proposed three aroused major discourses on Td: transcendence, problem solving, and transgression.…”

“…Transdisciplinarity (Td), however, goes one step further in the science/society interface (Muhar et al, 2013;Scholz et al, 2006;Vilsmaier, 2008). The objective is no longer the search for consensus but the search for articulations, preserving the different realities and confronting them in a controlled way.…”

Method-Based Higher Education in Sustainability: The Potential of the Scenario Method

“…Case studies focus on examples of sustainability issues and possible solutions to them. They can use fictive cases, use "authentic" documents as teaching material, or even tackle real cases which the project courses try to help resolve [24]. The advantages of this starting point for both students and teachers consist in the motivation gained from specific, practical questions, the additional benefit regarding real-world issues, and the possibility of offering active project work.…”