Training Melanoma Detection in Photographs Using the Perceptual Expertise Training Approach

Abstract

SummaryAlthough a deadly form of skin cancer, melanoma is treatable if detected early. However, current rule‐based training practices in melanoma detection are not effective. We assessed an innovative technique to train melanoma detection using the perceptual expertise principles. Participants in the training group were trained to categorize melanoma and benign lesions to 95% accuracy. Participants in the control group received no training. Prior to testing all participants reviewed the ABCDE rules. Training was evaluated by the pre and post tests using the Melanoma Detection Test where participants categorized images of melanoma and benign lesions. As compared to the control group, the training group showed significant improvement in melanoma detection and became less liberal (i.e., bias toward categorizing a lesion as melanoma), and both improvements maintained a week after the training. These findings indicate that perceptual expertise training is a promising approach to train melanoma detection.Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Perceptual learning in the identification of lung cancer in chest radiographs

“…The novices tested in this study performed at chance level before training. This differed from previous studies in which participants were trained to identify bone fracture or skin melanoma (Chen et al, 2017;Xu et al, 2016). The pre-training performance in those studies was above chance, suggesting that the abnormalities were discernible even without training.…”

“…Other fields emphasize the development of perceptual pattern templates that support the recognition of normal and abnormal images (van der Gijp et al, 2014). Perceptual learning can also complement conceptual knowledge, such as in the identification of melanoma (Xu, Rourke, Robinson, & Tanaka, 2016).…”

Visual perception training: a prospective cohort trial of a novel, technology-based method to teach melanoma recognition

“…Novices may develop perceptual expertise through experience or through targeted visual perception training (VPT). Previous work demonstrated that VPT successfully improved the ability of undergraduates to diagnose melanoma, although follow-up was limited to 1 week 5. This prospective cohort trial of preclinical medical students was performed to evaluate the effectiveness of a novel, technology-based VPT system for melanoma detection with retention assessed at 4 weeks.…”

Perceptual learning of lesions in mammograms induced by response feedback during training

“…In basic and clinical studies in which feedback is used to visually train subjects, partial feedback 20-21 or detailed feedback 22-23 has never been used systematically. Our results suggest that training using partial feedback is sufficient for PL of calcifications.…”