Towards circular economy – a wastewater treatment perspective, the Presa Guadalupe case

Abstract

Purpose In Mexico, only 19.3 per cent of industrial water is treated (Green-Peace, 2014, pp. 3-4), whereas municipal treatment levels are approximately 50 per cent (CONAGUA, 2014a). This paper aims to focus on how the wastewater treatment plant policy, from a circular economy perspective, is affected by the governance context at the Presa Guadalupe sub-basin. Circular economy can contribute to water innovations that help in improving water quality. However, such benefits are not easily achieved. This case provides an example of the complexity and challenges that the implementation of a circular economy model can face. Design/methodology/approach Data are collected via semi-structured in-depth interviews with the stakeholders that are members of the Presa Guadalupe Commission. The contextual interaction theory (CIT) is the theoretical basis for this analysis (Boer de and Bressers, 2011; Bressers, 2009). Findings The findings show that the wastewater treatment plant policy plays an important role in a circular economy model. Some incentives towards a circular economy model are already in place; however, the hurdles of a top-down implementation perspective, low availability of resources, prioritisation of short-term results, lack of enforcement of the “polluter pays” principle and a linear model of water systems need to be overcome. If Mexico wants to move towards a circular economy model and if the government wants to enforce sustainable development principles, wastewater treatment is a challenge that must be addressed. Originality/value There are few studies in the circular economy literature that have analysed its implementation under a governance arrangement perspective.

Learning from Failure and Success: The Challenges for Circular Economy Implementation in SMEs in an Emerging Economy

“…For instance, in some developed economies, specifically in Europe, CE is regulated via a top-down approach, with governments aligning or creating regional conditions that encourage the proliferation of CE initiatives across the country. In contrast, emerging economies are often characterized by corruption, the absence of strong legislation, and low monitoring and regulation compliance [11,25,29]. Additional challenges may include poor infrastructure development or its complete absence [30][31][32], and barriers associated with low environmental literacy, lack of social inclusion, and resource scarcity [33].…”

Challenges of Water Sensitive Cities in Mexico: The Case of the Metropolitan Area of Guadalajara

“…Despite the creation of wastewater treatment plants, there is still a deficit of treatment. This is a common situation in Mexico [69,70]. The local government has proposed the construction of more plants, but the number of discharges are ignored in spite of the existence of monitoring systems.…”

“…Lack of monitoring of the quantity and quality of wastewater flows make difficult to define the type of treatment. The wastewater treatment in general, is insufficient and inefficient [70]. Actually, when looking at wastewater treatment from a circular economy perspective important challenges still need to be overcome.…”

Energy and material assessment of municipal sewage sludge applications under circular economy

“…Modernization policy planning and implementation of municipal wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) in order to reduce negative environmental impact is a key element for a sustainable management in concordance with circular economy (CE) view [1][2][3]. Evolution of rapid techniques together with the development of fundamentally new sludge-processing stages thereby lead to energy consumption growth [4][5][6].…”