Toward A Broader Definition of Heat-Related Death: Comparison of Mortality Estimates From Medical Examiners' Classification With Those From Total Death Differentials During the July 1995 Heat Wave in Chicago, Illinois

Abstract

The classification of heat-related deaths solely according to body temperatures underestimates the magnitude of heat-related mortality during heat waves. Broader classifications are often used, but their utility in defining the mortality and identifying at-risk populations has not been evaluated. Using death data from the July 1995 heat wave in Chicago, the authors compared heat-related mortality rates based on the classification of heat-related deaths by the Cook County Medical Examiner's Office (CCMEO), with excess mortality rates based on total mortality differentials during and before the heat wave. In July 1995, the overall mortality in Chicago was 19 deaths per 100,000 population for heat-related mortality and 24 to 26 deaths per 100,000 population for excess mortality. Across Chicago community areas, the two mortality rates were closely related (r = 0.73-0.79; p < .01), but heat-related mortality rates were lower than excess mortality rates in community areas where excess mortality rates were higher (slope < 1; p < .01), a finding indicating an underestimation of heat-related deaths in such areas. The underestimation could not be explained by uncertainties in estimating excess mortality rates or by differences in socioeconomic and demographic characteristics among communities. These results support using the broader CCMEO classification of heat-related deaths as a relative indicator to target communities for prevention and relief efforts, but not as an adequate measure of actual heat-related mortality in a high-risk neighborhood.

Climate change, heat waves, and mortality projections for Chicago

“…Although some deaths may have merely been anticipated by a few days to weeks, Semenza et al (1999) estimated that only 26% of deaths were due to this type of displacement or "harvesting," leaving over 500 deaths directly attributable to the heat wave event. Even this number may be an underestimate, as Shen et al (1998) found that excess mortality rates during the Chicago heat wave were higher than the estimated heat-related mortality (24-26 per 100,000 as opposed to 19 per 100,000), likely due to an overly narrow classification of heat-related death.…”

The social impacts of the heat–health watch/warning system in Phoenix, Arizona: assessing the perceived risk and response of the public

“…However, the actual total is much higher since extreme heat results in increased mortality for many other causes of death, such as cardiovascular and respiratory disease (Shen et al 1998;Kilbourne 1997). The 1995 heat wave in Chicago was responsible for over 800 deaths alone, and estimates for the 2003 heat wave across Europe range from 22,000 to upwards of 50,000 deaths (Whitman et al 1997;WHO 2004;Brucker 2005).…”

The impact of major heat waves on all-cause and cause-specific mortality in France from 1971 to 2003

“…The resulting heat-related death count has been shown to be markedly smaller than the overall excess mortality observed during HW, particularly when the cause of death was not certified by specially trained physicians (Shen et al 1998). Excesses due to many causes of death other than heat-related causes (HRC) occur during HW.…”