Too many crying babies: a systematic review of pain management practices during immunizations on YouTube

Abstract

BackgroundEarly childhood immunizations, although vital for preventative health, are painful and too often lead to fear of needles. Effective pain management strategies during infant immunizations include breastfeeding, sweet solutions, and upright front-to-front holding. However, it is unknown how often these strategies are used in clinical practice. We aimed to review the content of YouTube videos showing infants being immunized to ascertain parents’ and health care professionals’ use of pain management strategies, as well as to assess infants’ pain and distress.MethodsA systematic review of YouTube videos showing intramuscular injections in infants less than 12 months was completed using the search terms "baby injection" and "baby vaccine" to assess (1) the use of pain management strategies and (2) infant pain and distress. Pain was assessed by crying duration and pain scores using the FLACC (Face, Legs, Activity, Cry, Consolability) tool.ResultsA total of 142 videos were included and coded by two trained individual viewers. Most infants received one injection (range of one to six). Almost all (94%) infants cried before or during the injections for a median of 33 seconds (IQR = 39), up to 146 seconds. FLACC scores during the immunizations were high, with a median of 10 (IQR = 3). No videos showed breastfeeding or the use of sucrose/sweet solutions during the injection(s), and only four (3%) videos showed the infants being held in a front-to-front position during the injections. Distraction using talking or singing was the most commonly used (66%) pain management strategy.ConclusionsYouTube videos of infants being immunized showed that infants were highly distressed during the procedures. There was no use of breastfeeding or sweet solutions and limited use of upright or front-to-front holding during the injections. This systematic review will be used as a baseline to evaluate the impact of future knowledge translation interventions using YouTube to improve pain management practices for infant immunizations.

Use of Mobile Devices, Social Media, and Crowdsourcing as Digital Strategies to Improve Emergency Cardiovascular Care

“…149 Images shared on the Internet could serve as a novel opportunity to better understand where an intervention is needed in changing public and healthcare providers' response to cardiovascular emergencies. 150 These represent targets for future research on the use of visual sharing to improve ECCC.…”

Pain neuroscience education on YouTube: a systematic review

“…Previous studies have reviewed videos with information about myocardial infarction (Pant et al, 2012), dental education (Knosel, 2011), and smoking cessation (Backinger et al, 2011). There are also a small number of published studies specifically reviewing pain-related information on YouTube, including a review of videos on pain management practices during infant immunization (Harrison et al, 2014), newborn blood tests (Harrison et al, 2018), and caregiver cancer pain management (Wittenberg-Lyles et al, 2014), as well as videos providing broader information about painful disorders such as arthritis (Singh, Singh & Singh, 2012). There is also a larger literature reviewing Internet-based resources, including websites and apps (Corcoran et al, 2009;Rosser & Eccleston, 2011;Bailey et al, 2013;De La Vega & Miró, 2014;Lalloo et al, 2015;Smith et al, 2015), for their usefulness and appropriateness for people with pain.…”

The Effect of Oral Glucose and Non-Nutritive Sucking in Reducing Needle-Related Procedural Pain among Infants

“…The result of the current study illustrated that, all caregivers in the experimental groups and in the control group used non-pharmacological pain relief measures for their infants during painful procedures either by consolability or pacifier, with consolability was the most common measure used among them. This result is emphasized by the study of Harrison et al (2014), about a systematic review of pain management practices during immunizations, stated that the distraction of infants in immunization by using talking or singing was the most commonly used pain management strategy in infants less than 12 months.…”