TMDL Implementation in Agricultural Landscapes: A Communicative and Systemic Approach

Abstract

Increasingly, total maximum daily load (TMDL) limits are being defined for agricultural watersheds. Reductions in non-point source pollution are often needed to meet TMDL limits, and improvements in management of annual crops appear insufficient to achieve the necessary reductions. Increased adoption of perennial crops and other changes in agricultural land use also appear necessary, but face major barriers. We outline a novel strategy that aims to create new economic opportunities for land-owners and other stakeholders and thereby to attract their voluntary participation in land-use change needed to meet TMDLs. Our strategy has two key elements. First, focused efforts are needed to create new economic enterprises that capitalize on the productive potential of multifunctional agriculture (MFA). MFA seeks to produce a wide range of goods and ecosystem services by well-designed deployment of annual and perennial crops across agricultural landscapes and watersheds; new revenue from MFA may substantially finance land-use change needed to meet TMDLs. Second, efforts to capitalize on MFA should use a novel methodology, the Communicative/Systemic Approach (C/SA). C/SA uses an integrative GIS-based spatial modeling framework for systematically assessing tradeoffs and synergies in design and evaluation of multifunctional agricultural landscapes, closely linked to deliberation and design processes by which multiple stakeholders can collaboratively create appropriate and acceptable MFA landscape designs. We anticipate that application of C/SA will strongly accelerate TMDL implementation, by aligning the interests of multiple stakeholders whose active support is needed to change agricultural land use and thereby meet TMDL goals.

Within-River Phosphorus Retention: Accounting for a Missing Piece in the Watershed Phosphorus Puzzle

“…Across the world, ever greater scrutiny is being focused on the sources of P entering rivers and the effectiveness of remediation measures 1,2 . In the U.S., total maximum daily loads (TMDLs) 3 have been implemented to attain target total phosphorus (TP) water quality criteria, through control of both point and non-point sources 4,5 . Setting TMDLs and identifying remedial options relies on appropriate and accurate apportionment of P loads across the watershed.…”

Participatory, dynamic models: a tool for dialogue

“…Other studies involving a participatory approach to spatial planning and modeling have found this to be an effective way to address highly complex and contentious problems compared with traditional planning approaches [24]. Integrating spatial information into the model was not possible using the Stella ® platform, but this represents a future key direction for the heat and human health modeling work.…”

Adoption potential of nitrate mitigation practices: an ecosystem services approach

“…Water quality initiatives are often hampered by limited farmer participation which has in turn been shown to be hindered by limited outreach capacity and inflexible policy (Lemke et al 2010, Jordan et al 2011. Facilitating broader farmer participation requires understanding of comprehensive farmer perspectives in order to 'calibrate' appropriate and effective programming.…”