Threat-Related Attentional Biases in Police Officers and Martial Artists: Investigating Potential Differences Using the E-Stroop and Dot Probe Task

Abstract

In this study, we investigated the possible development of threat-related attentional bias due to the work as a police officer. For this purpose, we compared four groups, differing with regard to their experience in policing and martial arts: (a) police officers with no experience in martial arts (n = 74), (b) martial artists (n = 50), (c) police officers with martial arts experience (n = 33), and (d) a control group (n = 48). Participants completed the Dot Probe Task, the Emotional Stroop Task, and the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory. The results on the Dot Probe and the Emotional Stroop Task showed that the groups did not differ with regard to threat-related attentional biases. However, the control group showed higher measures of trait anxiety compared with the other groups. The results are discussed in the light of police use of force and martial arts training, as well as with regard to optimizing psychological measures to capture functional threat-related attentional bias.

Studies on martial arts, fights and sports combat with police: a systematic review

“…Only five original studies were found, which was not expected. Our main findings are that all studies analyzed how MA/F/CS can help police officers in carrying out their duties even in stressful situations (RENDEN et al, 2015;RENDEN et al, 2015a;TORRES, 2018;STALLER et al, 2017) and how its practice can prevent injuries and reduce medical certificates (JIMÉNEZ et al, 2020). Figure 1 illustrates the main findings of this study.…”

The Way is in Training: Martial Arts-informed Compassionate Mind Training to enhance CFT Therapists’ Compassionate Competencies

“…The martial arts offer a well-developed platform to engage in such embodied practice [4]. Traditional martial artists are arguably extremely adept in the art of embodied self-regulation [51], evidenced by research that points to superior attentional, motivational switching and integrative capacities [52][53][54], as well as greater impulse control and distress tolerance in threatening situations [55,56]. Their training requires them to develop deeply embodied distress tolerance abilities in the face of antagonistic relational threats [4,6,57] and respond in a prosocially-driven co-regulatory manner [51,58,59], that is focused on neutralising/halting actions that cause suffering and reestablishing relational harmony [5,60,61].…”

Radically Embodied Compassion: The Potential Role of Traditional Martial Arts in Compassion Cultivation

“…Recent fMRI research into the effects of mind-body training through Budo in Kendo practitioners on the motivation network supports this notion, in that “resting vs. attentionally-driven” switching/change of motivation can be trained and becomes more efficient (Fujiwara et al, 2019 ), which is indicative of an unmoving/undisturbed/unfettered mind (Wilson and Takuan, 2012 ) which better affords an appropriate physical response. Research also suggests that martial artists are more endogenously prepared to engage with and respond to uncertainty (Johnstone and Marí-Beffa, 2018 ) and are more distress tolerant when faced with and despite repeated exposure to threatening situations (Staller et al, 2017 ), as well-having greater sustained attentional abilities and impulse control (Sánchez-López et al, 2013 ; Sánchez-Lopez et al, 2016 ). All of this combines to lead to skillful action that is reasoned, assertive and conflict-ending rather than mindlessly aggressive and designed to excessively hurt another.…”