The “Voice” Has It: Screen Reader Adoption and Switching Behavior Among Vision Impaired Persons in India

Abstract

We present results from a mixed methods study of screen reader use and switching behavior among people with vision impairments in India. We examine loyalty and experimentation with screen readers and find that the main drivers of adoption for early users differ significantly from the factors that drive continued use by advanced users. We discuss the factor that emerges as one of the strongest stated drivers of early adoption, TTS “voice” quality, particularly a “human-sounding voice” as one of the key features differentiating free/open source (FOSS) products from more expensive proprietary products. While the initial preferences are driven by voice quality, application support becomes more important over time as users speed up their sound settings and become more comfortable with the resultant non-human-sounding speech. We discuss these findings from two theoretical perspectives – first, through the application of the economics of behavior switching, and second, vis-à-vis novice and expert approaches toward new product adoption. We argue that these findings further our understanding of initial user comfort related to assistive technology adoption, and the impact of early technology choices on long-term technology switching behavior.

Assistive Technology to Enhance Access to Information for Student with Disabilities: A Case Study in Surabaya

“…The most famous screen reader is JAWS, which is followed by NVDA. This is in line with global figures, which show that JAWS is the most common screen reader, with NVDA coming in second (Mccarthy & Cutrell, 2014).…”

Do‐it‐yourself as a means for making assistive technology accessible to elderly people: Evidence from the ICARE project

“…To a much lesser extent research has emphasised the fact that access to AT products, either because of their high price or educational prerequisites, is often out of reach for certain groups of people, particularly the elderly. McCarthy et al (2013) report that companies developing innovative AT solutions commonly play on their first‐mover advantage to create lock‐in effects which do not always necessarily favour the best technology or service for users. Gibson et al (2019) criticise that a market‐driven approach creates “passive consumers with ‘need’ being defined by those providing technology rather than those receiving them.” Being the result of a century‐long ‘codification’ of best practices, Smith et al (2018) state that production, deployment, and support all occur within and under the control of one company or a tightly coordinated network of companies.…”

Screen Reading Software for Indian Users: A Challenge

“…Screen reader not able to explain the pictures, graphs etc. As the assistive technology is limited part in the market, the price of softwares are typically very high with single software costing approximately $1000 US (`65000 INR) [3]. People from poor community with vision impairments has a lot of influence from this high price of technology.…”