Presented herein
is a first major density functional theory (BP86/D3/STO-TZ2P)
survey of the energetics of saddling versus ruffling for a wide range
of dodecasubstituted metalloporphyrins with M = Ni, Cu, Zn, Pd, and
Pt. For the majority of X
8
TPP (i.e., β-octasubstituted-
meso
-tetraphenylporphyrin), the calculations indicated a
clear preference for the saddled conformation, consistent with a large
body of experimental data. The preference for the saddled conformation
relative to the ruffled conformation was found to vary from about
∼0.3–0.4 eV for Me
8
TPP derivatives up to
1 eV for I
8
TPP and (CF
3
)
8
TPP derivatives.
For X = Ph, that is, dodecaphenylporphyrins, the saddled and the ruffled
conformation are almost equienergetic, with even a slight preference
for the ruffled conformation in some cases. This finding provides
a satisfactory explanation for the X-ray crystallographic observation
of both saddled and ruffled conformations for dodecaphenylporphyrin
complexes as well as for spectroscopic evidence for conformational
mobility of these complexes in solution. The calculations also indicate
near-equienergetic saddled and ruffled conformations for
meso
-tetraacetylenyltetrabenzoporphyrins, again consonant with key crystallographic
findings. By and large, both the energetics and nonplanar distortions
of the metalloporphyrin derivatives correlated well with the Charton
and Sterimol B
1
steric parameters of the peripheral substituents.