The Use of Energy Models in Local Heating Transition Decision Making: Insights from Ten Municipalities in The Netherlands

Abstract

In 2018, the Dutch national government announced its decision to end natural gas extraction. This decision posed a challenge for local governments (municipalities); they have to organise a heat supply that is natural gas-free. Energy models can decrease the complexity of this challenge, but some challenges hinder their effective use in decision-making. The main research question of this paper is: What are the perceived advantages and limitations of energy models used by municipalities within their data-driven decision-making process concerning the natural-gas free heating transition? To answer this question, literature on energy models, data-driven policy design and modelling practices were reviewed, and based on this, nine propositions were formulated. The propositions were tested by reflecting on data from case studies of ten municipalities, including 21 experts interviews. Results show that all municipalities investigated, use or are planning to use modelling studies to develop planning documents of their own, and that more than half of the municipalities use modelling studies at some point in their local heating projects. Perceived advantages of using energy models were that the modelling process provides perspective for action, financial and socio-economic insights, transparency and legitimacy and means to start useful discussions. Perceived limitations include that models and modelling results were considered too abstract for analysis of local circumstances, not user-friendly and highly complex. All municipalities using modelling studies were found to hire external expertise, indicating that the knowledge and skill level that municipal officials have is insufficient to model independently.

An agent-based exploration of the effect of multi-criteria decisions on complex socio-technical heat transitions

“…Developing a quantitative model to compare combinations of heating systems and insulation measures was not a purpose of our work. See [83] for an overview of energy models used for decision making in the heat transition in The Netherlands.…”

Open Data and Models for Energy and Environment

“…The sixth paper of this special issue, by Chiosa et al [6], proposes an innovative anomaly detection and diagnosis methodology to automatically detect anomalous energy consumption in buildings, in addition to performing a diagnosis on the sub-loads that are responsible for anomalous patterns. In the next paper, Henrich et al [7] analyse the impact of energy models in decision making processes for energy transitions in ten municipalities in the Netherlands. In the eight paper, Manfren et al [8] review the role of energy modelling and analytics for energy transitions in the construction sector.…”

Role of Local Governments in Green Deal Multilevel Governance: The Energy Context

“…Energies 2023, 16 The European Commission's Green Deal serves as a proposition to assume a leading role and serve as a model for other countries when implementing the goals of the Paris Agreement. Through its initiatives and actions, the EU aims to demonstrate effective strategies for achieving the objectives of the agreement.…”