The Use of BMI in the Clinical Setting

Abstract

BMI has been recommended for evaluating overweight and obesity in children and adolescents in the clinical setting. Definitions of overweight and obesity are based on percentile cutoff points. There are both strengths and limitations of BMI for this use. The strengths include the fact that BMI is cheap and relatively easy to use. The weaknesses include the fact that BMI percentiles are not widely used, and categorization of BMI percentiles may not adequately define risk of comorbid conditions. In addition, percentiles are not optimal for stratifying children and adolescents with very high BMI. Alternatives to the use of BMI and BMI percentiles include waist circumference to evaluate regional fat deposition and replacement of percentiles with z scores. Despite limitations, BMI and BMI percentiles have great utility in the clinical setting and the potential to be even more useful as BMI is used more frequently and more appropriately by primary care providers. Additional research on alternatives or adjuncts to BMI is needed.

Western and Mediterranean dietary patterns among Balearic Islands’ adolescents: socio-economic and lifestyle determinants

“…For example, individuals with increased muscle mass may also have increased BMI (33) . On the other hand, individuals with decreased lean body mass and increased adiposity may also be misclassified by assessment with BMI (33) . Alvero-Cruz et al (34) showed that the FMI had higher accuracy for overweight screening than BMI.…”

Measurement of Neck Circumference and Its Correlation with Body Composition in a Sample of Students in São Paulo, Brazil

“…The assessment most widely used is the body mass index (BMI) [1], which is not a sensitive indicator of either the amount or the distribution of body fat in this age group [6,7,8]. Body fat distribution is important due to the known association between some diseases and a greater accumulation of abdominal fat, regardless of age and the amount of total body fat [9,10].…”

Evaluación Del Estado Nutricional en Menores De 5 Años: Concordancia De Índices Antropométricos en Población Indígena De Chiapas

“…Partiendo de la definición de obesidad (exceso de tejido adiposo) de la OMS, y que afecta de manera adversa la salud y el bienestar (28), los indicadores idóneos para definirla deben ser aquellos que cuantifiquen la magnitud del tejido adiposo (29), de ahí que la definición ideal tendría que basarse en la estimación del porcentaje de grasa corporal (20). Sin embargo, las mediciones que se obtienen son del IMC, que representa tanto la masa grasa como la masa libre de grasa, por lo que es un indicador de peso y no de adiposidad (30). Por ello, se ha cuestionado el uso del IMC en poblaciones donde prevalece la estatura baja (31).…”