The United Kingdom's Human Rights Act 1998 in Theory and Practice

Abstract

Thisessay assesses the significance of the United Kingdom's Human Rights Act (HRA) 1998 on legal theory and practice. Part II considers its constitutional context and significance; Part III deals with whether the European Convention on Human Rights has been ‘incorporated’. Part IV deals with its entry into force. The two principal methods used by the HRA to relate to (1) statutory interpretation and (2) a duty on public authorities or those exercising public functions. We consider these in turn. Part V analyses the interpretative obligation contained in the Act, the power for higher courts to make a ‘declaration of incompatibility’, and effects of such a declaration. Part VI explores the new statutory duty imposed by the Act. Part VII assesses the Act's remedial provisions. Part VIII notes the particular provision made for freedom of expression and freedom of religion. Part IX discusses the issues of ‘horizontal effect’ and the ‘margin of appreciation’. Part X concludes with an assessment of the significance of the HRA on legal theory and practice—just how big a difference has it made and will it make?

‘Dogs Are “Registered”, People Shouldn’t Be’: Legal Consciousness and Lesbian and Gay Rights

“…With the rise in the importance of international human rights norms, equal rights discourse has arguably become even more entrenched in western societies (McGoldrick, 2001). Indeed, the argument that as humans we are all entitled to the equal protection of fundamental civil and political rights has reached such a state of ascendancy, that almost all claims for equality find their basis within this framework:…”

“…As can be expected when looking at arguments for the legal recognition of same-sex relationships, many respondents used rights rhetoric, or called upon discourses of common humanity to argue for rights to equality and the right to marry. With the rise in the importance of international human rights norms, equal rights discourse has arguably become even more entrenched in western societies (McGoldrick, 2001). Indeed, the argument that as humans we are all entitled to the equal protection of fundamental civil and political rights has reached such a state of ascendancy, that almost all claims for equality find their basis within this framework:…”

Accommodating human values in the climate regime

“…The act is widely recognised as an innovative development in legal thinking, and has been hailed as 'imaginative and in a sense revolutionary.' 114 The underlying principle is that human rights are integrated into all United Kingdom law and policy, raising awareness and beginning a new culture in the development of the morals and values reflected in the HRA. 115 The act and the mechanisms deriving therefrom have since resulted in greater scrutiny and an enhanced recognition and understanding of human rights.…”