The role of the organizational champion in achieving health system change

Abstract

In healthcare there is a long held wisdom that 'champions' are a key aspect of organizational change. Drawing on organizational management theory, we examine the role of champions in three health and social care organizations in England as they attempt to move services to a remote model of delivery. The delivery of remote care is a significant policy in the UK and elsewhere, but its introduction has been challenging. Over three years ethnographic methods were used to analyse the role of organizational champions in implementing remote care.Cases were local authorities and associated primary care trusts. Participants were champions and organizational members involved in implementation.Our study shows that organizational champions are highly effective in the first phase of adoption, when change is contained within distinct sub-sets of practice. Moving beyond local contexts the effectiveness of the champions varied. Identification centred on the remote-care work. This identification enabled the champions to motivate others and move beyond their normally prescribed roles, contributing to innovation ideas, processes and practices. When required to shift their work organization-wide, and share ideas outside their professional culture, some champions responded with resistance, resulting in a lack of innovation spread.These results caution against allowing change to become positioned within the remit of a few individuals. Whilst this strategy may be initially beneficial, the role of champion may be less useful, even detrimental to progress, in the later stages of implementation, particularly if identification with the new circumstances is not established.

Moving beyond local practice: Reconfiguring the adoption of a breast cancer diagnostic technology

“…Surgeons were unanimous about the patient benefit and their role as organizational champions clearly made a difference (Hendy and Barlow, 2012). Our data however, suggests that whilst organizational champions can be important facilitators of technology adoption, reconfigurations of work practices within and across departments and professional groups (Ferlie et al, 2005) to support the adoption of BLNA requires much more.…”

Examining the Development of Positive Space in Health and Social Service Organizations: A Canadian Exploratory Study

“…However, given the historical invisibility of diverse LGBTQ people in home care literature, the study raises questions about whether home care agencies would recognize the importance and urgency of moving forward on this. Building home care sector capacity using organizational champions at multiple levels of organizations as a strategy to foster the development of positive space (Hendy & Barlow, 2011) may be a way forward to foster awareness and action.…”

The Role of Organizational Factors in the Provision of Comprehensive Women's Health in the Veterans Health Administration

“…It is also possible that a champion is needed prior to the adoption of a women's health clinic and, ultimately, in the later stages of adoption a champion is no longer needed. 46 Longitudinal analysis and qualitative evaluation would better identify the role of a champion in the adoption of women's health models in the VHA.…”