Cognitive styles bear on the organization and control of attention, thought, feelings, and motives in cognitive processing. Highlighted here are two attentional cognitive styles of sharpfocus versus broad-focus scanning and serial scanning for signal detection versus parallel-process scanning that apprehends incidental information. Defensive styles bear on the organization and control of intrusive affects in cognition; they represent consistent modes of accommodating anxiety and conflict so as to maintain reasonably adaptive cognitive functioning. Because the four major defensive styles associated with obsessive-compulsive, paranoid, hysterical, and impulsive neuroses are distinguished by differential modes of attentional scanning, the two attentional cognitive styles offer a heuristic means of organizing these defensive styles in behavioral expression.
STYLE IN THE ORGANIZATION AND DEFENSE OF COGNITION l
Samuel Messick Educational Testing ServiceThe concept of style refers to stable individual differences in the manner or form of psychological functioning as distinct from substantive content or the level of functioning. Because personal styles are consistencies in the way psychological substance is processed rather than to consistencies in the substance itself, they may entail mechanisms for the organization and control of processes that cut across substantive areas (Messick, 1987). To the extent that personal styles display generality in the organization and control of attention, thought, feelings, and motives, they constitute important cross-cutting variables because they bridge cognitive, conative, and affective modes of functioning. Being selfconsistent regularities in the manner or form of human activity implies that to some extent styles are both integrative and pervasive.Several kinds of styles have been distinguished empirically, including expressive styles, response styles, cognitive styles, learning styles, and defensive styles (Furnham, 1995;Grigorenko & Sternberg, 1995;Messick, 1994). This paper concentrates on cognitive styles and defensive styles as well as on their potential interrelationships. In particular, two cognitive styles of attentional scanning are examined in relation to four prominent defensive styles associated with obsessive-compulsive, paranoid, hysterical, and impulsive neurotic pathologies (Shapiro, 1965). Because these defensive styles are distinguished one 1 This paper was presented at the Second Spearman Seminar, University of Plymouth, UK, July 1997. Acknowledgements are gratefully extended to Walter Emmerich, Ann Jungeblut, Richard Snow, and Lawrence Stricker for their helpful comments on the manuscript. 2 from another in part by their distinctive modes of attentional behavior, the question naturally arises as to how they relate, if at all, to the two more general cognitive styles of attentional scanning, one of which refers to sharp-focus versus broad-focus scanning and the other to serial scanning for signal detection versus parallel-process scanning that apprehends...