This study is concerned with the design development implementation, and evaluation of a standardized method for teaching English diction for choral music performance. Review and analysis of various approaches to choral diction reveal that such methods gnerally are inconsistent and based primarily on tradition and personal preference. A review of research in the language, speech, hearing, and acoustical sciences facihtates a more systematic foundation for product planning and design. The product, the Articulatory Diction Development Method (ADDM), focuses on developing kinesthetic awareness and on control ling the speech articulators through various sung exercises. This type of approach is essential since the practices that transfer from speech into song generally are habitual and unconscious.After 12 weeks of preiminary and prototype testing and refining, the ADDM was implemented for 6 weeks in three high school choirs. retraining and posttraining recordings provided data for evaluating the method's effctiveness. Evaluation was based on choral tone preference responses and text intelligibility scores from a group of 47 judges. The method was significantly effective in improving choral tone and textual intelligibility in all three choral ensembles.
Robert E. Fisher, West VirginiaUniversity, Morgantown The Design, Development, and Evaluation o f a Systematic Method f or English Diction i n Choral Performance Diction in choral music performance serves two primary functions. It assists in transmitting the textual message. It also brings to choral performance a large set of vowel colors and consonant articulations that affect the choir's overall tonal qualities. Appropriately, singers' approach to diction is generally considered important in the development of ensemble sound.Although many methods and quasi-methods are used in choral rehearsals, most have not been tested to assess their effectiveness in developing good tone quality or in maximizing text intelligibility in choral singing. By and large, these methods are inconsistent and based on tradition, opinion, and personal preference.The study's purpose was to develop, implement, and evaluate a standard systematic methodology for the teaching and practice of English diction in choral performance on the secondary school level and beyond. The Articulatory Diction Development Method (ADDM) is a product of this study. Downloaded from JRME 271
PRIMARY APPROACHES TO CHORAL DICTIONCurrent methods in the instruction and practice of English diction in vocal and choral music may be divided into three main categories: (1) "smear-slur" diction, (2) rhythmic diction, and (3) discrete phonetic diction. Uris (1971), who laid a foundation for smear-slur diction with a concept she identified as "scientific legato" (p. 55), suggests that smear-slur (the linkage of each speech sound to adjacent speech sounds without separate articulations) is the basis for both the singer's technique and the audience's response to the song. Linkage in speaking and singing, according to Uris, can be j...