The organizational justice effect among criminal justice employees: A meta‐analysis^*

Abstract

Organizational justice has been shown to be an important predictor of criminal justice employees’ work‐related perceptions, attitudes, and behaviors. In this study, we take stock of the organizational justice effect on criminal justice employees’ work outcomes by subjecting the literature to a meta‐analysis. Multilevel modeling based on 1,924 effect size estimates drawn from 143 studies (95 independent data sets) was used to establish the empirical status of the organizational justice effect. The results indicate a sizeable relationship between organizational justice and justice system employee work outcomes (Mz = .256, CI = [.230, .283]). The findings also demonstrate that the organizational justice effect size varies slightly across several methodological variations. Specifically, the organizational justice effect size is larger when the concept is measured with scales that contain survey items tapping into all four dimensions of justice. Also, we found that outcome type, presence of confounding mechanisms, research design, and sample characteristics moderate the justice effect. We conclude that organizational justice theory is a useful framework for developing a more theoretically informed understanding of justice system employees’ work outcomes. We discuss the theoretical implications of the meta‐analytic findings and avenues for future research based on the results.

Policing the COVID-19 pandemic: police officer well-being and commitment to democratic modes of policing

“…When officers feel fairly treated by their organisation, then, their sense of positive identification with it is enhanced (Bradford et al 2013). Such identification may be linked not only to internalisation of organisational goals (Tyler and Blader 2003), but also to a sense that they are supported and 'enabled' by the organisation to enact those goals (Wolfe and Lawson 2020). Officers' attitudes and behaviours towards policing may thus stem from identification with the police organisation and internalisation of the values it presents to itself and its members: in the UK, this includes that physical force should be used proportionately and only when necessary; and that policing should be delivered in as open, honest, and respectful manner as possible.…”

Perceived fairness of transfers and job satisfaction among police officers

“…The limited policing research on the topic measures organizational fairness in different ways (Wolfe and Lawson, 2020). The first approach measures an overall perception of organizational fairness.…”

Police self-legitimacy and democratic orientations: Assessing shared values

“…The research thus far demonstrates that officers who possess greater self-legitimacy are more likely to express positive attitudes toward democratic policing principles (Bradford and Quinton, 2014; Tankebe, 2019; Tankebe and Mesko, 2015; Trinkner et al, 2016), as well as a greater willingness to engage the community (Wolfe and Nix, 2016). This line of research is relatively new, and there remains a need to explore these relationships in more detail.…”