The Myth of Social Class and Criminality: An Empirical Assessment of the Empirical Evidence

Abstract

Thirty-five studies examining the relationship between social class and crimeldelinquency are reduced to comparable statistics using instances where the relationship was studiedfor specific categories of age, sex, race, place of residence, data type, or offense as units of analysis. The findings from 363 instances are summarized and patterns are identified. The overall results show only a slight negative relationship between class and criminality, with self-report studies reflecting lower associations than official statistics studies. Moreover, analysis demonstrates a clear historical decline in magnitude of association to the point where both self-report and official statistics studies done in the current decade find no class variation. This historical trend is shown to be due to changes in the findings from studies using official statistics as indicators of criminality. Alternative interpretations are discussed, but all lead to serious doubts about the adequacy of theories of deviance that contain assumptions of class differences.

Low Socioeconomic Status and Mental Disorders: A Longitudinal Study of Selection and Causation during Young Adulthood

“…7 Our finding of only a weak association between SES and externalizing behavior problems at midadolescence is consistent with other literature reviewed by Tittle and Meier (1991) and Tittle, Villemey, and Smith (1978). adults (Kessler et al 1994;Dohrenwend et al 1992; but see also Weissman et al 1991, who report a nonsignificant SES/depression association).…”

Does parental income matter for onset of offending?

“…Contrary to these theoretical assumptions, the claim from an early literature review was that crime is spread relatively evenly across levels of socio-economic statuses (Tittle et al, 1978). This led to debates on whether this finding could be due to measurement issues on crime and/or SES (Braithwaite, 1981;Thornberry & Farnwort, 1982).…”

Cascades of Violence: War, Crime and Peacebuilding Across South Asia

“…At the individual level, people who are poor are much more likely to commit direct crimes of interpersonal violence such as assault, murder and rape, and common property crimes such as robbery, burglary and theft (Braithwaite 1979; but see Tittle et al 1978). Unemployment may have a stronger impact on increasing the criminality of individuals with prior criminal records or with a propensity to crime than individuals who lack such predispositions (Aaltonen et al 2013: 587).…”