“…The inclusiveness of scientific culture is also illustrated in Pacey’s brief biography of Joseph Dawson, Nonconformist minister turned Yorkshire iron master, who, from the 1790s, discussed the chemistry of iron making with fellow manufacturers and amassed a geological collection via an international network of scientists and Moravians. The success of Swansea's Science Institution (1835) in shaping ‘civic identity’, Miskell shows, reflected an inclusive appeal to ‘the middle and upper social ranks’ and its bringing together of Swansea's resort and leisure facilities, its distinguished resident scientists, and its science‐oriented, metalliferous manufacturers. Scottish intellectual life was more combative.…”