The influence of sex, race, and age on pain assessment and treatment decisions using virtual human technology: a cross-national comparison

Abstract

PurposeStudies in the United States have found that patients’ sex, race, and age influence the pain assessment and treatment decisions of laypeople and medical professionals. However, there is limited research as to whether people of other nationalities make pain management decisions differently based on demographic characteristics. Therefore, the purpose of the following study was to compare pain assessment and treatment decisions of undergraduate students in Jordan and the United States as a preliminary examination of nationality as a potential proxy for cultural differences in pain decisions.MethodsVirtual human (VH) technology was used to examine the influences of patients’ sex (male or female), race (light-skinned or dark-skinned), and age (younger or older) on students’ pain management decisions. Seventy-five American and 104 Jordanian undergraduate students participated in this web-based study.ResultsAmerican and Jordanian students rated pain intensity higher in females and older adults and were more likely to recommend medical help to these groups, relative to males and younger adults. Furthermore, Jordanian participants rated pain intensity higher and were more likely to recommend medical help for all patient demographic groups (ie, sex, race, age) than American participants.ConclusionThis is the first cross-national study that compares pain decisions between undergraduate students. The results suggest that sex, race, and age cues are used in pain assessment and treatment by both Americans and Jordanians, with Jordanians more likely to rate pain higher and recommend medical help to patients. Additional research is needed to determine the cultural determinants of these differences.

Sex-Based Differences in Patient-Reported Outcomes After Arthroscopic Rotator Cuff Repair

“…Societal expectations and perceived gender stereotypes may also play a role, as one study found that pain in male and female patients is assessed and treated differently by independent observers. 34…”

Evaluating psychosocial contributions to chronic pain outcomes

“…Furthermore, these expectations decreased the activation of pain-related brain regions, offering an explanation of how expectations influence pain sensations. Preliminary evidence suggests that expectations for pain sensitivity and willingness to report pain differ based on race and ethnicity, which may help explain race difference in pain sensitivity 245, 246 . There are also notable race differences in pain coping.…”

The effect on pain of three different nonpharmacological methods in peripheral intravenous catheterisation in adults

“…The sample consisted of 120 healthy male individuals who came to the centre to donate blood voluntarily. Gender (Alabas, Tashani, Tabasam, & Johnson, 2012;Bartley & Fillingim, 2013;Gautschi et al, 2016) and age (Ozdemir, Pınarcı, Akay, & Akyol, 2013;Torres et al, 2013;Tu grul & Khorshıd, 2014) factors may affect the perception of pain, and so, only males between the ages of 30 and 40 were included in the study.…”