The Impact of Railway Stations on Residential and Commercial Property Value: A Meta-analysis

Abstract

Railway stations function as nodes in transport networks and places in an urban environment. They have accessibility and environmental impacts, which contribute to property value. The literature on the effects of railway stations on property value is mixed in its finding in respect to the impact magnitude and direction, ranging from a negative to an insignificant or a positive impact. This paper attempts to explain the variation in the findings by meta-analytical procedures. Generally the variations are attributed to the nature of data, particular spatial characteristics, temporal effects and methodology. Railway station proximity is addressed from two spatial considerations: a local station effect measuring the effect for properties with in 1/4 mile range and a global station effect measuring the effect of coming 250 m closer to the station. We find that the effect of railway stations on commercial property value mainly takes place at short distances. Commercial properties within 1/4 mile rang are 12.2% more expensive than residential properties. Where the price gap between the railway station zone and the rest is about 4.2% for the average residence, it is about 16.4% for the average commercial property. At longer distances the effect on residential property values dominate. We find that for every 250 m a residence is located closer to a station its price is 2.3% higher than commercial properties. Commuter railway stations have a consistently higher positive impact on the property value compared to light and heavy railway/Metro stations. The inclusion of other accessibility variables (such as highways) in the models reduces the level of reported railway station impact.

Assessing the impacts of Light Rail Transit on urban land in Manila

“…A recent study by Debrezion et al (2007) also reported positive increments in commercial property values closer to railway stations in the Netherlands. ey also found that railway stations are expected to have a higher positive effect on commercial properties compared to residential properties for relatively short distances from the stations.…”

Long-term impacts of transport infrastructure networks on land-use change: an international review of empirical studies

“…Demographic and spatial LU impacts of TINs, measured by changes in population and employment density, land cover and development type (residential, office, commercial, industrial) are reviewed, whereas economic outcomes measured by economic performance indicators such as the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and property values are excluded (examined elsewhere by authors such as Banister & Berechman, 2001;Debrezion, Pels, & Rietveld, 2007). The focus on empirical findings means that ex-ante studies on landuse-transport modelling (LUT) are outside the scope of this paper (for an overview, see Iacono, Levinson, & El-Geneidy, 2008;Wegener, 2004).…”

Risk Perception and Vulnerability of Value: A Study in the Context of Commercial Property Sector

“…The total aggregated score obtained for each sub-criterion was then normalized into a dimensionless effect score between 0 and 1. This is a usual choice for the domain of vulnerability assessment in disaster studies (Cutter et al 2009). …”