The impact of patients’ gender, race, and age on health care professionals’ pain management decisions: An online survey using virtual human technology

Abstract

Background Previous literature indicates that biases exist in pain ratings. Healthcare professionals have been found to use patient demographic cues such as sex, race, and age when making decisions about pain treatment. However, there has been little research comparing healthcare professionals’ (i.e., physicians and nurses) pain decision policies based on patient demographic cues. Methods The current study used virtual human technology to examine the impact of patients’ sex, race, and age on healthcare professionals’ pain ratings. One hundred and ninety-three healthcare professionals (nurses and physicians) participated in this online study. Results Healthcare professionals assessed virtual human patients who were male and African American to be experiencing greater pain intensity and were more willing to administer opioid analgesics to them than to their demographic counterparts. Similarly, nurses were more willing to administer opioids make treatment decisions than physicians. There was also a significant virtual human-sex by healthcare professional interaction for pain assessment and treatment decisions. The sex difference (male > female) was greater for nurses than physicians. Conclusions Results replicated findings of previous studies using virtual human patients to assess the effect of sex, race, and age in pain decision-making. In addition, healthcare professionals” pain ratings differed depending on healthcare profession. Nurses were more likely to rate pain higher and be more willing to administer opioid analgesics than were physicians. Healthcare professionals rated male and African American virtual human patients as having higher pain in most pain assessment and treatment domains compared to their demographic counterparts. Similarly the virtual human-sex difference ratings were more pronounced for nurses than physicians. Given the large number of patients seen throughout the healthcare professionals’ careers, these pain practice biases have important public health implications. This study suggests attention to the influence of patient demographic cues in pain management education is needed.

Differential Effect of Patient Weight on Pain-Related Judgements About Male and Female Chronic Low Back Pain Patients

“…30,32,35,37,78 Also similar to previous research is our finding that women's pain, across all weight categories, was more attributed to psychological factors than was men's. 32,35,66 In line with recent conceptualizations, (mis)attribution of pain as psychological in nature could be considered a form of discounting.…”

“…35,37 Similarly in experimental studies, women's pain is judged to be less intense, treated less aggressively, and prescribed psychological treatment more often compared to equivalent men. 30,32,33,78 These systematic gender differences in pain appraisals and pain care decisions are inconsistent with treatment guidelines and are likely to adversely affect patient outcomes.…”

“…Observers watched video segments of real chronic pain patients performing standardized physical tasks. Based on current guidelines for pain assessment/treatment 12,61 and studies suggesting gender and weight differences in pain appraisals and pain treatment recommendations, 32,33,55,64,78 we asked observers to provide ratings in three broad domains: 1) patient pain, 2) pain attributes, and 3) treatment recommendations. We hypothesized main effects of patient gender and weight, such that the pain of female and overweight patients would be discounted (i.e., rated as less intense and interfering, more exaggerated, more attributed to psychological than medical factors, and less in need of painspecific care) relative to that of male and normal-weight patients.…”

The case of veterinary interprofessional practice: From one health to a world of its own

“…This has implications for maintaining a positive working environment and providing the best possible care by making use of the knowledge and skills of all members of the veterinary team. In human healthcare, similar findings relating to nurses being more prone to rate pain higher, or more willing to administer pain relief are seen, 41,42 This study also demonstrated the relevance of interprofessional working, especially communication, for quality of care and patient safety via the identification of errors. Errors relating to challenges of the system, rather than an individual's mistake, are increasingly recognised in healthcare 43 and are beginning to be researched in the veterinary field, 44 as explored in a further publication from this overarching study.…”

Because Women’s Lives Matter, We Need to Eliminate Gender Bias

“…Disparity greater for nurses than physicians. 31 Despite ACC/AHA PAD guidelines, at discharge, women are significantly less likely than men to be prescribed 3 recommended therapies: statins, aspirin, and β-blockers.…”