The impact of operational and strategic management on liner shipping efficiency: a two-stage DEA approach

Abstract

This paper aims to measure the relative efficiency of liner shipping companies in terms of operational and financial performance and further investigates the impact of strategic and operational management on efficiency performance. A two-stage Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) approach is employed combining DEA and Tobit regression, which has been extensively used in various research areas. 14 liner shipping companies from the top 20 container lines in terms of fleet capacity were included in this analysis. The results suggest that the firm size (in terms of TEU capacity), ship size, the ratio of chartered vessels, use of new vessels, and the formation of alliances all make a positive contribution to the financial performance of liner shipping companies. Ship age and ship type did not show a significant contribution to the financial performance and, for the operational performance, any of these determinant factors were not significant. This analysis is able to provide container shipping companies with information on the managerial and strategic implications of how managerial options influence operational and financial performance. In addition, maritime researchers will benefit from this study, measuring the efficiency of container shipping companies and the factors that influence efficiency, as this study is the first to investigate and model factors of relative efficiency of container shipping companies to the authors' knowledge.

Designing a sustainable maritime supply chain: A hybrid QFD–ANP approach

“…Liner shipping companies strive to achieve high levels of operational and financial efficiencies for survival (Bang et al, 2012). The thrust towards higher supply chain integration is putting increased demand on the container transport system.…”

A Framework Proposal for Evaluating the Organizational Reliability and Capability of a Liner Shipping Operator in a Fuzzy Context

“…Competition among liner shipping operators (LSOs) continues to evolve as a result of structural changes within the industry [1]. This industry has witnessing the evolution from liner conferences to market consolidation where three main alliances are formed which are THE Alliance Ocean Alliance and 2M.…”

“…cartel agreements) were established in the 1970s with the purpose to limit competition by setting fixed prices and supply coordination among shipping lines. At the beginning of their establishment, these cartels were found to be useful, especially in indulging in retaliatory measures against independent LSOs which forced them to leave the trade route or join the cartel [1]. However, this cartel structure is viewed as irrelevant in today"s market due to evolution within the industry.…”

“…One useful mechanism is competing through service reliability. Under these new challenging circumstances, LSOs should seek high levels of operational and financial efficiencies for survival, generating the required level of cargo capacity with the minimum level of resources [1].…”

Efficiency - Profitability Mapping of Shipping and Marine Transportation Companies: Evidence from Indonesia

“…The study of Wang, et al, (2014) was about market and operating efficiencies of international shipping companies listed in Bloomberg Shipping Indices. Meanwhile, Bang, et al, (2012) have done research on the relative efficiency of liner shipping companies in terms of operational and financial performance and further investigates the impact of strategic and operational management on efficiency performance using a two-stage Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) approach. Some of previous researches show that shipping companies have high efficiency, but some of them indicate that shipping companies have low efficiency.…”