The Impact of Heterogeneity and Ill-Conditioning on Diffusion Model Parameter Estimates

Abstract

Assessment of accurate market size and early adoption patterns is essential to strategic decision making of managers involved in new-product launches. This article proposes methodology that explains changes in parameter estimates of the Bass model, (coefficient of innovation), (coefficient of imitation), and (market penetration rate) by direction of "extra-Bass" skew in the data, or equivalently, by underlying heterogeneity of the population. This research shows significantly opposite patterns of these parameter estimates, depending on skew of the diffusion curve detected by a generalized model, i.e., the gamma/shifted Gompertz (G/SG) model, which embeds the Bass model as a special case. The G/SG model originally presented in Bemmaor (1994) is based on two assumptions: (1) Individual-level times to first purchase are distributed shifted Gompertz and (2) individual-level propensity to buy follows a gamma distribution across the population. We assume that the scale parameter of the shifted Gompertz distribution is constant across consumers. The advantage the G/SG model has over alternative diffusion models such as the nonuniform influence model is that its cumulative distribution function takes a closed-form expression. In line with Van den Bulte and Lilien (1997), we analyze these opposite patterns from simulated data using the G/SG model as the true model and 12 real adoption data sets. The patterns are: (1) as the level of censoring decreases, the estimates of and decrease and those of increase when data exhibit more right skew than the Bass model and (2) the estimates of and increase and those of q decrease when data exhibit more left skew than the Bass model. For the simulated data, we manipulated four dimensions: (1) "extra-Bass" skew in the data, (2) ratio , (3) speed of diffusion, and (4) error variance. Both results of the simulated data and the real adoption data sets confirm the existence of two opposite patterns of parameter estimates of the Bass model depending on "extra-Bass" skew. When the model is correctly specified with simulated data, estimates of increase and those of decrease for both the Bass and the G/SG models. The estimates of increase as one adds data points only for the G/SG model. No significant tendency in parameter estimates of was detected for the Bass model. As for ill-conditioning issues, systematic changes in the parameter estimates of the G/SG model can be substantially larger in some cases than those obtained with the Bass model, even though the data were generated by taking the G/SG model as the true one. Therefore, model complexity can aggravate the tendency for parameters to change systematically as one adds data points. The forecasting results from the simulated data show the supremacy of the G/SG model. It provides more accurate results than the Bass model in the one-step ahead, two-step ahead, and three-step ahead forecasts. With the real data set, the G/SG model provides more accurate one-step ahead forecasts than the Bass model, but the model's forecasting performance det...

The sales effect of word of mouth: a model for creative goods and estimates for novels

“…Yet, this finding is in line with previous simulation studies, and hence not specific to the model studied here. Van den Bulte and Lilien (1997), as well as Bemmaor and Lee (2002), obtain similar results for the less complex 3-parameter Bass diffusion model.…”

“…Word of mouth in Bass-type models cannot generate product failures or successes, because it has no effect on the total number of buyers. Moreover, scholars have argued that ignoring buyer heterogeneity can lead to biased estimates in applied research (Van den Bulte and Lilien, 1997;Bemmaor and Lee, 2002).…”

“…Unfortunately, neither asymptotic nor small-sample properties of such NLS estimators are known (Boswijk and Franses, 2005); but their bias and consistency may be studied by means of a Monte Carlo simulation. See Van den Bulte and Lilien (1997) and Bemmaor and Lee (2002) for simulation studies of the Bass (1969) Boswijk and Franses (2005) propose an alternative estimation method for the Bass model based on weighted least squares and argue that it has better properties than the NLS approach, which has been implemented widely in similar applications. However, their approach is not applicable to the proposed diffusion model in a straightforward manner.…”

Single firm product diffusion model for single-function and fusion products

“…However, Van den Bulte (2004) cautions that Pae and Lehmann's (2003) finding may be a methods artifact since several simulation studies (van den Bulte and Lilian, 1997;Bemmaor and Lee, 2002) have similar findings.…”

Social learning-based O2O model for innovative information diffusion

“…Based on micro decision theory, Duan et al established a single potential user decision model under the condition of certainty and uncertainty, and further extended to the macro level model [29]. Bemmaor and Lee deduced overall level diffusion model from the individual heterogeneity hypothesis, through forecast sales of 12 kinds of new products, and found that the model has higher predictive power than the Bass model [30]. Wang and Sun analysed the adoption behaviour of consumers to replace part of new products, then proposed non replace market diffusion model by diffusion concept and new parameters [31].…”