The Impact of a Change on the Size of the Smoke Compartment in the Evacuation of Health Care Facilities

Abstract

Evacuation in health-care facilities is complex due to the physical impairment of the patients. This kind of evacuation usually requires the assistance of the workforce members. A proposed change of NFPA 101, Life Safety Code, would increase the maximum allowable size of a smoke compartment (a space within the building enclosed by smoke barriers on all sides that restricts the movement of smoke) in health-care occupancies from 2,090 m2 to 3,700 m 2 , almost double the size. This study aims to analyse the impact of this change in the required time for evacuating patients during a fire in order to understand the consequences of that potential change. This paper is focused on the area where the patient's rooms are located. The evacuation scenario is a floor plan comprised of four smoke compartments. To analyse the proposed change, the smoke barriers between two adjacent compartments were removed in a floor plan and three ratios of number of patients per one staff member were considered (4:1, 3:1 and 2:1). A computational methodology was conducted to calibrate the model STEPS for simulating assisted evacuation processes. In addition, Fire Dynamic Simulator (FDS) was used to simulate the fire and smoke spread in a table and a PC to compare fire and evacuation results The evacuation results show that the change of the smoke compartment size increases the mean evacuation time by 23%; however, the fire results show that the available safe egress time is 16 min for both smaller and large smoke compartment. The ratio of the number of patients per staff member is also a strong factor that increases the evacuation up to 82% when comparing the ratios of 2 patients per staff member and 4 patients per staff member. BLIND Manuscript without contact information Click here to view linked References

Evacuation Solutions for Individuals with Functional Limitations in the Indoor Built Environment: A Scoping Review

“…Solutions targeted towards individuals with sensory impairments focused on improving the evacuation path accessibility. A full list of the identified solutions is found in Table 5 [66,[70][71][72][73][74][75][76][77][78][79][80][81][82][83][84].…”

Dynamic optimisation of evacuation route in the fire scenarios of offshore drilling platforms

“…Building Information Modelling (BIM) has been explored and integrated with FDS to evaluate the evacuation in case of fire [14,24,25] . Evacuation software tools such as STEPS [26] , Pathfinder [27] and SIMULEX [28] have also been combined with FDS to study the changes of critical factors in fire scenarios and analyze the process of evacuation affected by these factors.…”

Evacuation in Buildings Based on BIM: Taking a Fire in a University Library as an Example

“…Ruggiero Lovreglio et al provided new pre-evacuation data collected in four evacuations of the same university library and illustrated that unplanned evacuations had higher pre-evacuation times [ 8 ]. At present, scholars at home and abroad have conducted extensive research on the problem of evacuation in public places, mainly focusing on performance-based fire protection design [ 9 , 10 , 11 ], planning escape routes based on algorithm models [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ], the impact of fire smoke spread on evacuation [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ], changes in psychological characteristics and behavior of personnel during evacuation [ 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ], and so on. In terms of performance-based fire protection design, Khorasani et al provide a comparative analysis of the fire performance of a floor system designed following prescriptive- and performance-based approaches [ 24 ].…”