The financial vulnerability trap: using latent transition analysis to explore the dynamics of consumers’ financial vulnerability over time

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of the paper is to examine how psychological characteristics predict membership of and transitions between states of higher vs lower financial vulnerability – and vice versa – over time. Design/methodology/approach This research uses a dynamic latent class model (latent transition analysis) to explore the dynamics of consumers’ financial vulnerability over time using longitudinal data obtained by repeatedly administering a measure of financial vulnerability. Findings This research finds that consumers in a state of lower vulnerability are “fragile” in having a relatively high likelihood of moving to a state of higher vulnerability, whereas those in a state of higher vulnerability are “entrenched” in having a relatively low likelihood of moving to a state of lower vulnerability. This pattern of results is called the “financial vulnerability trap.” While financial self-efficacy explains state membership, the consideration of future consequences drives state transitions. Research limitations/implications Future research could follow consumers over a longer period and consider the role of alternative psychological characteristics besides those examined. Practical implications This research provides practitioners with actionable insights regarding the drivers of changes in consumers’ financial vulnerability across time, showing the value of financial self-efficacy and the consideration of future consequences when developing strategies to prevent consumers from sliding from a state of lower to higher financial vulnerability over time. Originality/value There is scant research on financial vulnerability. Further, prior research has not examined whether and how consumers’ psychological characteristics help explain their membership of and transitions between states of different levels of financial vulnerability over time.

An empirical analysis on household financial vulnerability in India: exploring the role of financial knowledge, impulsivity and money management skills

“…Besides these individual risk factors, this study also found a range of psychological risk factors such as time preference, money management skills, consideration for future consequences, saving orientation, financial self-efficacy and so on particularly important. Hoffmann et al. (2020) added to these findings, as they reported that financial self-efficacy not only mediates the relationship of financial vulnerability with financial outcomes but also limits the consumer’s likelihood of experiencing financial vulnerability in the first place.…”

Allowing early access to retirement savings: Lessons from Australia

“…From a policymaking perspective, this could be viewed as a reassuring outcome; despite concerns about the limited controls in place to validate eligibility in the application process, the scheme appears to have been primarily accessed by individuals who genuinely needed financial support. At the same time, our findings should raise concerns about whether the scheme may further entrench individuals who were financially vulnerable to begin with ( Hoffmann et al, 2021 ).…”

Let your past define your future? How recalling successful financial experiences can increase beliefs of self‐efficacy in financial planning

“…Despite these limitations, our study contributes to the hitherto scarce literature on how to increase consumers' financial self‐efficacy and provides a set of actionable implications for policy makers and other practitioners on how to design and implement (more) effective interventions to financially empower (vulnerable) consumers (see e.g., Hoffmann et al ., 2020).…”