“…It is important to study the quality of the attention process during dying and death, but not the quality of the experience itself Thank you for these insightful comments and I agree there are issues around how to collect and analyse patient experience. However, nursing research is primarily about studying the quality of the patient experience as explored in the following articles: (Brady, 2012, Coronado et al, 2017, Day et al, 2015, Embrey, 2008, Kamal et al, 2018, Matthews and Cornwell, 2012, Parra et al, 2017, Taylor, 2011, Thomas et al, 2017, These articles are based on the premise that studying the quality of the patient experience can improve care. It is impossible to study the quality of the patient experience after death, (because the patients aren't there to ask) hence the carers, both formal and informal act as surrogates for the patient.…”