The ethics of marketing in Muslim and Christian communities

Abstract

Purpose -This paper takes advantage of the closeness of two secular, separated communities on the island of Cyprus to study how controversial products and forms of offensive advertising can be related to levels of religiousness, time usage and temporality. The resulting observations are then offered as insights into the notion of ethics in the two religious groups and how these might influence marketing to multicultural communities. Design/methodology/approach -The findings are based on a small-scale survey of 530 students (211 Christians, 302 Muslims and 18 undeclared) who responded to a questionnaire distributed at two privately owned, English speaking institutions, one in the north and one in the south part of Cyprus. Findings -This study indicates a high degree of commonality between Muslim and Christian students living in the adjoining communities in Cyprus. In general, overall reactions were tolerant of most products and forms of advertising, but where there were differences occurred there were specific reactions to the forms of the advertising. Significant differences were found across the communities when devoutness was tested especially regarding products that were of a sexual nature.Research limitations/implications -The relatively small numbers studied in the special case of Cyprus and the focus on students could limit the generalisation of these results. Practical implications -The results raise some issues for marketing segmentation and image use. For instance, positive and forward-looking images would stimulate most of the group regardless of their level of faith. Originality/value -This paper identifies commonalties and also ontological differences that could have implications for global marketing campaigns.

Marketers’ Perception about Marketing Ethics: Evidence from Malaysia

“…Hence, Malays, Chinese and Indians marketers did not have any significant differences in their marketing ethics. The results are also consistent with the findings of Waller et al (2005) and Gibbs et al (2007), who stated that the people living in multi cultural groups tend to be more moderate or liberal so as to "maintain social and cultural harmony between the various groups.…”

‘Shockvertising’: An exploratory investigation into attitudinal variations and emotional reactions to shock advertising

“…White () also identified religion as a country‐specific factor that can contribute to how people perceive and interpret provocative advertisements. Differences have also been identified between Muslim and Christian communities when viewing advertising of a sexual nature (Gibbs et al , ). Boddewyn and Kunz ( p. 13) found that Muslim countries were especially disapproving of ‘all kinds of salacious displays and even indirect sexual references’.…”

Controversial Advert Perceptions in SNS Advertising: The Role of Ethical Judgement and Religious Commitment

“…In particular, studies have examined the influence of one particular religion, that of Islam, on perceptions of advertising content (Luqmani, Yavas and Quraeshi, 1987;Michell and Al-Mossawi, 1999) revealing differences in controversial advert perceptions between highly religious individuals and those less devoted to religion. Similarly, other scholars have identified variations in responses to controversial advertising, based on individuals' affiliation to a particular religion (e.g., Islam or Christianity) (e.g., Gibbs, Ilkan and Pouloukas, 2007), albeit without taking into consideration variations in the individual's intra-personal and/or inter-personal religious commitment. More recently, religious commitment has been found to influence consumer perceptions of sexual appeals in print media through the mediating effect of ethical judgement (Putrevu and Swimberghek, 2013).…”