The Effects of Agglomeration on Socio-economic Outcomes: A District Level Panel Study of Punjab

Abstract

This paper examines the variation of agglomeration across districts over time in Punjab and analyses the effects of agglomeration on socio-economic outcomes in terms of social inclusion and efficiency of firms at the district level in Punjab. Earlier studies in this regard faced multiple problems since they used cross-sectional data. To bridge the gap, a newly constructed panel data from CMI is used. Factor Analysis technique is used to analyse socialinclusion variable, in addition to some other control variables as well. Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) with bootstrap technique (performed in R) is used to calculate district-wise firm efficiency. The study argues that agglomeration is a logical consequence of China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) through an increase in the economic activity in various districts of the province. The results show that district agglomeration has a positive effect on the average district-wise efficiency of firms and has a positive statistically significant relation with social inclusion. Interesting implications arise from results, setting up clusters in urbanised rather than highly urbanised areas under CPEC can be a game changer for the economy of Pakistan especially Punjab since it has significant potential positive effects on the economy of Punjab. JEL Classification: D62, I38, L52, R13 Keywords: Agglomeration, CPEC, Social Inclusion, Factor Analysis, Data Envelopment Analysis, Efficiency

An empirical investigation of socio-economic impacts of agglomeration economies in major cities of Punjab, Pakistan

“…The demand for housing also has a significant positive relationship with education, in the long-run. Educated people move to cities for better living conditions (Azhar & Adil, 2016). Overall, the results show that AEs have a significant long-run impact on education index.…”

“…Agglomerations of localized and urbanized economies have a strong impact on formation of new firms, their scale of operation, employment, enrollment levels, and social-inclusion. However, this impact varies with firms' size (Azhar & Adil, 2016;Chaudhry & Haroon, 2015).…”

“…Few empirical studies have examined the effects of agglomeration economies; on formation of new firms; on efficiency of manufacturing industries; and on firms' turnover (Burki & Khan, 2011;Haroon, 2013;Nasir, 2017). Furthermore, two studies identified positive impact of district agglomerations on firm efficiency, social inclusion, and economic outputs, in case of Punjab, Pakistan (Azhar & Adil, 2016;Chaudhry & Haroon, 2015). The developmental progress of cities of Punjab shows that the environmental conditions of the cities are poorer than the economic and social conditions.…”

Evaluating land use/cover change associations with urban surface temperature via machine learning and spatial modeling: Past trends and future simulations in Dera Ghazi Khan, Pakistan

“…In 1970, a flux of labor migration toward the middle east countries (e.g., the United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia) (Azhar, 2008), and flood events in 1992, 1998, 2010(Ahmed et al, 2014Munir and Iqbal, 2016;Garcia et al, 2018) acted as trigger points that initiated urban migration from rural areas. Such migration, especially from the de-excluded areas, led the high land price and renters, unplanned construction activities, congested road development, improper green space management, and removal of agriculture and scrubland.…”

Where to Locate? The Correlation Between Spatial Proximity and Location Choice of New Firms: The Case of Pakistan*

“…One of the few countries analyzed in the context of this research is Pakistan, although the research is relatively scant: Burki and Khan (2010) also found that industrial concentration is a prominent characteristic of all districts of Punjab but is more apparent in the urbanized areas of the province. Azhar and Adil (2016) show that district‐level agglomeration is positively correlated with the efficiency of firms.…”