The Duality of Empowerment and Marginalization in Microtask Crowdsourcing: Giving Voice to the Less Powerful Through Value Sensitive Design

Abstract

Crowdsourcing (CS) of micro tasks is a relatively new, open source work form enabled by information and communication technologies. While anecdotal evidence of its benefits abounds, our understanding of the phenomenon's societal consequences remains limited. Drawing on value sensitive design (VSD), we explore microtask CS as perceived by crowd workers, revealing their values as a means of informing the design of CS platforms. Analyzing detailed narratives of 210 crowd workers participating in Amazon's Mechanical Turk (MTurk), we uncover a set of nine values they share: access, autonomy, fairness, transparency, communication, security, accountability, making an impact, and dignity. We find that these values are implicated in four crowdsourcing structures: compensation, governance, technology, and microtask. Two contrasting perceptions-empowerment and marginalization-coexist, forming a duality of microtask CS. The study contributes to the CS and VSD literatures, heightens awareness of worker marginalization in microtask CS, and offers guidelines for improving CS practice. Specifically, we offer recommendations regarding the ethical use of crowd workers (including for academic research), and call for improving MTurk platform design for greater worker empowerment.

Micro-entrepreneurs, Dependent Contractors, and Instaserfs: Understanding Online Labor Platform Workforces

“…Most labor platform studies to date have examined only one platform, and depending on context and the authors' academic discipline have referred to the people doing the work as freelancers (Kokkodis, Papadimitriou, & Ipeirotis, 2015), entrepreneurs (Sundararajan, 2014), crowdworkers (Deng, Joshi, & Galliers, 2016), driver-partners (Hall & Krueger, 2015), service providers (Allon et al, 2012), agents (Gurvich, Lariviere, & Moreno, 2015), or sellers (Moreno & Terwiesch, 2014). As we show, however, none of these labels are a good fit for workers on all labor platforms.…”

Designing for Digital Transformation: Lessons for Information Systems Research from the Study of ICT and Societal Challenges

“…For Chan et al (2016), the ICT artifact is online hate-related information. Deng et al (2016) delve into specific features of the Amazon Mechanical Turk platform along with its terms of use and the practices of requestors. Despite these differences, two main strategies emerged from the articles to achieve an appropriate balance.…”

Exploring Online and Offline Informal Work: Findings from the Enterprising and Informal Work Activities (EIWA) Survey

“…For the ICT fields, researchers focus on innovations in e-commerce platforms, such as omnichannels (cross-channels), consumer-to-consumer (C2C) and peer-to-peer (P2P) markets for online user experiences and creative usage, and new technologies employed by traditional bricks-and-mortar store locations to enhance the customer experience (Deng et al, 2016;Karmarkar, 2015;Kazan et al, 2015;and Hamari et al, 2015).…”