“…The 21 st -century learning in the VUCA (Volatility, Uncertainty, Complexity, and Ambiguity) era requires human resources with competence, and the student achievements are directed at learning skills and innovations, including critical thinking skills (CTS) (Mafarja et al, 2022;Wisudariani & Sriasih, 2017), problem-solving skills, creativity (Sandopa & Doyan, 2022), and innovation (Ahmed & Asiksoy, 2021). The speed of technology and information not only affects our lifestyle or the development of education out there, but also affects how to educate students (Troise et al, 2022).…”