“…When only bubble-bearing MI were available for study, some workers have acknowledged potential contributions from the bubble by stating that the CO 2 contents and pressures determined from the MI are minimum values (Anderson and Brown, 1993;Cervantes and Wallace, 2003;Spilliaert et al, 2006;Kamenetsky et al, 2007;Johnson et al, 2008;Vigouroux et al, 2008;Ruscitto et al, 2010;Esposito et al, 2011). Others report that bubbles are present, but do not further discuss their potential contribution to MI volatile abundances (Lowenstern, 1994;Roggensack et al, 1997;Walker, 2003;Liu et al, 2006;Mangiacapra et al, 2008;Lloyd et al, 2013). Schipper et al (2010) argue that, based on a positive correlation between CO 2 , H 2 O, and MgO in their highFe MI, the bubbles in these MI were likely either trapped heterogeneously or only contain a vacuum and should be ignored in either case.…”