The Commoditization of IT: Evidence from a Longitudinal Text Mining Study

Abstract

While Information Technology (IT) has been identified by researchers as a source of strategic advantage for businesses, commentators have argued that this reality may not endure. These commentators argue that the growing ubiquity of IT makes it a commodity input rather than a scarce and valuable resource. We examine CEOs' Letters to Shareholders, one of the primary statements of corporate strategy, using both content analysis and latent semantic analysis, a text mining technique. Examining these letters allows us to investigate whether IT may be declining in strategic importance over time. We examine 160 annual reports from firms in the healthcare industry, covering a ten-year span of time, from 1997 through 2006. Our results indicate that the strategic emphasis placed on IT may be increasing, but its association with firm performance is declining. Our findings imply that as markets become more competitive, IT management capabilities and the strategic use of IT take on increasing importance. Our findings also imply that CEOs' perception of the importance of IT is a necessary but not a sufficient condition for improved firm performance. This article makes two primary contributions. First, we present an empirical examination of the issue of IT commoditization as a complement to existing anecdotal discussions. Second, we demonstrate the use of latent semantic analysis (LSA), a relatively new methodology for analyzing textual data, one that is evolving into an alternative to the well-known content analysis technique.

How to Generate More Value from IT: The Interplay of IT Investment, Decision Making Structure, and Senior Management Involvement in IT Governance

“…He suggested that the competitive advantage that IT provided at the beginning (when it was expensive and scarce) had vanished because of its availability to everybody. Proponents of this view claimed that IT investment had no strategic value to organizations because their competitors could duplicate the new IT applications (Beccalli, 2007;Lee, Song, Baker, Kim, & Wetherbe, 2011;Tangpong, 2008). However, Schrage (2003) quickly refuted the argument of resource scarcity being key to strategy.…”

Commoditization and IT Product Innovation Strategies from an IT Firm Perspective

“…This is complemented by Carr (2003), who argues that IT can be used to supplement and improve strategy implementation. Lee et al (2011) indicate that the strategic emphasis placed on IT may be increasing, but that its association with firm performance is declining. Their research suggests that the routine and radical innovation types from the Innovation Landscape Map have a positive effect on business performance.…”

Benefits and Barriers in Mining the Healthcare Industry Data

“…By implementing data mining in health insurance plans, insurers have been able to identify more false claims than ever before, which allow them to save millions of dollars. In addition, data mining systems have eased the pains and efforts of operating a hospitals' health care administration (Manchur, 1998;Lee et al, 2011).…”