The attitudes of psychiatric hospital staff toward hospitalization and treatment of patients with borderline personality disorder

Abstract

BackgroundNegative attitudes towards patients with borderline personality disorder (BPD) may affect their treatment. We aimed to identify attitudes toward patients with BPD.MethodsClinicians in four psychiatric hospitals in Israel (n = 710; psychiatrists, psychologists, social workers and nurses) were approached and completed questionnaires on attitudes toward these patients.ResultsNurses and psychiatrists reported encountering a higher number of patients with BPD during the last month, and exhibited more negative attitudes and less empathy toward these patients than the other two professions. The whole sample evaluated the decision to hospitalize such a patient as less justified than the decision to hospitalize a patient with Major Depressive Disorder. Negative attitudes were positively correlated with caring for greater numbers of patients with BPD in the past month and in the past 12 months. Nurses expressed the highest interest in studying short-term methods for treating patients with BPD and a lower percentage of psychiatrists expressed an interest in improving their professional skills in treating these patients.ConclusionsThe findings show that nurses and psychiatrists differ from the other professions in their experience and attitudes toward patients with BPD. We conclude that nurses and psychiatrists may be the target of future studies on their attitudes toward provocative behavioral patterns (e.g., suicide attempts) characterizing these patients. We also recommend implementing workshops for improving staff attitudes toward patients with BPD.

Personality Disorder in Childhood and Adolescence comes of Age: a Review of the Current Evidence and Prospects for Future Research

“…Researchers and clinicians should always be wary of the potential harmful effects of diagnostic labeling. PD generally-and borderline and antisocial (including psychopathy) PD more specifically-are stigmatized among some mental health professionals, patients, the judicial system, and society at large (244)(245)(246)(247). However, well-intentioned clinicians who purposefully refrain from using PD diagnoses with adolescent patients in order to avoid stigma or discrimination may thereby unwittingly be reinforcing and perpetuating the very stigma that they wish to avoid (170).…”

Mental health nurses’ attitudes, behaviour, experience and knowledge regarding adults with a diagnosis of borderline personality disorder: systematic, integrative literature review

“…It is important to systematically appraise and synthesise the available evidence as some studies (Bodner et al . , ) have concluded that mental health nurses hold the poorest attitudes of all professional groups. We have recently conducted a systematic review of interventions that aimed to improve the attitudes and/or behaviour of groups of clinicians, including mental health nurses, towards people diagnosed with borderline personality disorder (Dickens et al .…”

When personality is the problem: Managing patients with difficult personalities on the acute care unit

“…Managing patients with personality disorders begins by recognizing that these individuals evoke strong responses from even the most seasoned professional . Reactions toward people with personality disorders can range from a need to care for and protect the patient to feelings of futility or contempt .…”